Top Ten Thoughts
1. Loan Defaults
Uncertain and anxious over the economic downturn and impact of
9/11, hospitality industry lenders have virtually disappeared and hotel
financing has become notably scarce while nationwide delin-quency rates
on hotel loans doubled in the fourth quarter of 2001. Approximately
13% of hotel loans with collateral in the state of Florida were delinquent
at the end of 2001, many of them as a result of 9/11. Orlando in particular,
the largest hotel inventory in the state and second in the country after |
Top Ten Thoughts
1. Loan Defaults
2. Airport Expansions and Renovations
3. Convention and Conference Center
Expansions
4. Urban Revitalization
5. Cruise Industry Growth
6. Vacation Ownership
7. Condominium-Hotels
8. Native American Casinos
9. Environment
10. Cuba |
|
Las Vegas, accounts for the largest share of defaults in the nation, approximately
25%. Unlike the early 1990s, however, when hotel lenders consoled themselves
by fore-closing on troubled properties, lenders today are taking a different
approach and are working with borrowers and third party advisors to restructure
their loans and monitor the assets in hopes of reaching a solution. Delinquencies,
nonetheless, should continue in 2002 and are not expected to decline until
mid-year.
2. Airport Expansions and Renovations
To support growing levels of tourism visitation as well as corporate
travel, major airports in Florida are undergoing renovations and expansions
in excess of $4 billion. Despite the decline in passenger traffic across
the nation as a result of 9/11, the state�s airports are still moving forward
with short-term projects and expansion programs already underway. Long-term
projects have not been cancelled but many are under scrutiny and may be
deferred until passenger traffic picks up. A $400 million expansion project
is planned for the Tampa International Airport, $250 million of which is
currently underway with the remainder to be phased out over several years.
Orlando International Airport is currently engaged in a $1.2 billion expansion
including the construction of a fourth runway. Orlando�s passenger traffic
surpassed the 30 million mark in 2000 and its long-term expansion plans
are expected to increase capacity to 75 million passengers upon completion
in 15 to 20 years. Miami International Airport is currently under-going
a nearly $2 billion expansion program, which includes a fourth runway as
well as north and south terminal expansions with total completion anticipated
by mid-2006. The Fort Lauderdale International Airport is also executing
a $655 million expansion through 2004, as it anticipates that its 15.8
million-passenger level in 2000 will surpass 30 million by 2020.
3. Convention and Conference Center Expansions
Florida�s convention centers continue to expand to accommodate an ever-growing
demand for flexible convention space. An expansion of the Broward County
Convention Center, located in Fort Lauderdale, is currently underway, with
an additional 50,000 square feet of exhibit space to be delivered in February
2002. After 10 years of planning, construction of the $75 million, 350,000-square
foot Palm Beach convention center broke ground in June 2001 and is anticipated
to be completed by the fall of 2003. The expansion of the Orange County
Convention Center in Orlando will add approximately one million square
feet of exhibit space to the center by the end of 2003. Although no specific
plans have been announced, Miami is currently scrutinizing its fragmented
inventory and formulating a strategy to increase its competitiveness. Upon
completion of approximately 1.4 million additional square feet of convention
space, Florida should be poised to capture an increasing number of group
room nights during the next few years.
4. Urban Revitalization
As Florida�s suburbs become increasingly crowded and urban sprawl continues,
more efforts are being focused on redeveloping the downtown core of major
cities as a center of activity. The revitalization of Florida�s downtown
areas is drawing both tourists and businesses, as demonstrated by the success
of Las Olas Boulevard in Fort Lauderdale and Clematis Street and City Place
in West Palm Beach. In Jacksonville, the 966-room Adam�s Mark Hotel
is expected to serve as a catalyst for new development while in Daytona
Beach, the $250 million Ocean Walk Village redevelopment project is anticipated
to further enhance the destination. In Miami, the Heat�s American
Airlines arena has led the way for new real estate development including
the $334 million Performing Arts Center for the Miami Ballet, Opera, and
Symphony, to be built proximate to the Arena. Plans for a new baseball
stadium for the Florida Marlins are still under consideration despite initial
funding problems. Several other significant downtown mixed-use projects
are currently underway, including the Four Seasons Hotel & Tower, Espirito
Santo Plaza and the $1 billion Miami One development. Upon completion of
these developments, hotels planned for Florida�s downtown areas hope to
benefit from their location within walking distance of financial centers
during the day and supporting retail/entertainment establishments at night.
5. Cruise Industry Growth
In 2000 alone, passenger demand grew by 16.8% to a total of 6.9
million passengers, driven in part by an 11% increase in the number of
berths in state-of-the-art cruise ships. Moreover, the cruise industry
is anticipated to add approximately 50% additional capacity to the North
American market over the next five years. 2001, however, proved to be a
disappointing year for the industry as Port Canaveral�s passenger traffic
was down approximately 8% through August compared to the same period in
2000. The Port of Miami, on the other hand, experienced a
moderate 0.8% increase in passenger traffic during its 2001 fiscal
year, ended September 30. During September and October, however, the port
began experiencing signs of weakening passenger traffic compared to 2000,
posting declines of 12.5% and 17.6%, respectively. The decline was attributed
not only to weakening consumer demand but also to the loss of several cruise
liners seized by creditors. Although discounting techniques to lure back
passengers have resulted in bookings at or above the prior year levels,
they have cut into corporate revenues. Fortunately, the 2001 holiday season
experienced strong demand with bookings at or near 2000 levels in response
to lower rates. The rerouting of itineraries to leave from domestic ports
within easy driving distance from several markets also helped to bolster
demand post 9/11. Despite the failure of Ft. Lauderdale-based Renaissance
Cruises and the bankruptcy of Miami-based American Classic Voyages, a possible
merger of Royal Caribbean and P&O Princess Cruises would solidify South
Florida�s title as the world�s cruise capital, controlling approx-imately
80% of the world�s cruise capacity. Cruise industry professionals are bullish
on the globalization of the industry and key demand growth indicators.
As such, cruise demand is anticipated to gain momentum by late 2002 and
early 2003. Although the cruise industry lends minimal impact on the overall
lodging industry, it may present a direct threat to the leisure segment
and draw more guests away from resort destinations and theme parks.
6. Vacation Ownership
Vacation ownership companies continue to diversify into new products
and market segments. The industry has evolved from fixed weeks to floating
weeks and diverse point-based programs, offering greater flexibility to
owners. More affluent buyers also have their own selection of fractional
products, including independent and brand-affiliated resorts. Following
state-wide lodging trends, vacation ownership properties have experienced
lower occupancies after 9/11 and sales have declined during 2001 in response
to the recession and a decline in travel, which has impacted the level
of prospective consumers visiting properties. Orlando remains the timeshare
capital of the United States and Marriott�s Horizons mid-level product
is one of the latest additions to the city�s timeshare market. The Villas
at Disney�s Wilderness Lodge, a new themed product, opened this past winter
and Disney has already announced another vacation ownership resort, Disney�s
Beach Club Villas, scheduled to open in the fall of 2002, as well as plans
to convert a portion of the Disney Institute�s rooms to vacation ownership.
As major leisure markets in the United States become highly developed with
timeshare projects, it is possible that long-term cannibalization of hotel
products may occur.
7. Condominium-Hotels
Condominium-hotels, which many of us remember as a bold new concept
of the early 1980s, have resurfaced as a hot new development trend in Florida.
Particularly prominent in traditionally seasonal resort areas, this interesting
hybrid between investment and second home properties is becoming increasingly
popular from Miami Beach to the Florida Panhandle. These projects are expected
to remain attractive for developers seeking instant financing and to buyers
seeking help to defray mortgage costs for vacation properties. Conflicting
interests between developers and hotel operators, however, remain an ongoing
challenge. Condominium developers typically seek to minimize public space
and maximize living space, while hotel operators seek the opposite. Often,
developers focus on selling units and give little attention or regard to
the needs of the hotel operation. These conflicting interests result
in challenging development, marketing, and operating issues.
8. Native American Casinos
Floridians have repeatedly voiced their opposition towards legalizing
casino gambling in Florida. Their efforts, though, have not prevented the
Seminoles and Miccosukees, two Native American tribes, from establishing
as many as six gambling ventures in South Florida. The state, however,
considers their casinos to be illegal and infringing upon Florida Law,
as the tribes have not obtained a "compact," a license from the federal
government to open a casino on tribal land, to establish their operations.
While the issues remain unresolved, the Seminoles have partnered with the
Cordish Company to develop a $300 million, 750-room Hard Rock Hotel and
Resort in Hollywood anticipated to open by fall of 2003. In Tampa, a 250-room
Hard Rock Hotel and Casino is also anticipated to open by late fall of
2003, with a cost of more than $130 million. The purchase of a $28.7 million,
1,124-acre parcel in Osceola County in 2001 is yet another indication of
the tribe�s intent to establish another significant venture in the state.
9. Environment
The protection of the environment and the adverse impact that new and
existing development may have on Florida�s ecosystems are matters of concern
for officials and residents throughout the state. Fears of unplanned and
disorganized development, as well as new construction that may result in
regional ecological imbalances has led city executives to issue moratoriums
in Naples and The Keys to control urban sprawl. The Bush administration
is also using caution as it considers oil-drilling opportunities off the
Panhandle; Vice President Dick Cheney has suggested that the administration
would try to keep any new drilling about 100 miles from the state�s coast.
Florida also recently obtained an important win by having a $43.4 million
budget for beach restoration projects along the eastern shore approved
by the House of Representatives; the budget is $34.5 million more than
what was originally proposed by President Bush. Seasonal wild fires continue
to impact visitation to and within the state, as smoke from the blazes
force officials to close interstate highways and detour traffic to alternate
roads. Tampa�s Busch Gardens, for example, suspended operations of its
tour buses from Orlando in late February 2001 due to closed sections of
Interstate 4. Droughts throughout Central and South Florida may also adversely
impact tourism to the region as The Everglades become particularly dry,
diminishing the amount of observable wildlife and attractiveness of the
area.
10. Cuba
Despite former President Clinton�s efforts to loosen policy on Cuba,
further changes are not expected under the Bush Administration. The novelty
of a new and exotic destination that is 12 times as large as Puerto Rico,
has 4,000 keys, 100 miles of beaches and is only 90 miles away from Key
West is attracting many curious Americans and many more value-seeking European
tourists. Cuba, however, faces numerous challenges, including weak infrastructure
and a lack of hotel and airlift capacity relative to well-established destinations
in Florida and the Caribbean. Furthermore, a history of human rights issues,
labor practice violations, a communist controlled economy and a lack of
hard currency suggest that this island nation still has a long way to go
to position itself as a competitive Caribbean destination.
While the Miami area exhibited positive rate growth in 2001 due to an
increasing presence of luxury hotels, annual occupancy reached a 10 year
low as a result of oversupply combined with poor performance over the last
four months of the year. A weakening of the national and Latin American
economies, fear of flying and a surge in new hotel development are anticipated
to result in further declines in occupancy and average daily rate for 2002,
with a possible rebound by early 2003.
Major Demand Changes
The horrific events of 9/11 compounded by the U.S. recession and political
and economic crises in Latin America sent the Miami tourism industry into
a tailspin. Given the area�s dependence on the Latin American commercial
and banking sector coupled with an overwhelming majority of visitors arriving
by air, the speed of recovery for Miami is expected to lag the overall
state and U.S. lodging markets.
Despite recent events, the city remains focused on servicing the needs
of an increasingly sophisticated leisure and business traveler as well
as providing the proper environment for local business to thrive. A rapid
transformation is occurring and numerous projects are expected to reshape
the Miami skyline over the next several years. Several mixed-use projects,
which are expected to impact the office and residential markets, include
the Espirito Santo Plaza and the Four Seasons Hotel and Tower, which are
currently under construction, and the $1 billion Miami One mixed-use development.
Revitalization of the area north of downtown along Biscayne Boulevard is
another major focus. The city is planning a $334 million Performing Arts
Center on Biscayne Boulevard within walking distance of the Arena, which
is expected to help transform Miami into an important cultural center.
The structure is expected to occupy 570,000 square feet and house the ballet
opera house, concert hall, and studio theater. Upon its completion in 2005,
the center is expected to have an estimated economic impact of $690 million.
In the long term, the center should help reverse a decline in property
values in the currently depressed surrounding neighbor-hoods and spur significant
commercial and residential development.
Furthermore, the development and renovation of several cultural attractions
including the $10 million Patricia and Phillip Frost Museum of Art, the
$6.5 million renovation of the Actor�s Playhouse and the $5 million refurbishment
of the historic Seminole Theater are also expected to enhance the area.
Discussions to build the $385 million, retractable-roof stadium for
the Florida Marlins have progressed, although the final location and source
of funds have yet to be determined. In addition, the redevelopment of existing
attractions such as the $46 million relocation of Parrot Jungle and Gardens
to Watson Island and the $3 million renovation of Miami Metrozoo should
provide more attractive alternatives for Miami visitors. Miami will continue
to serve as a haven for international shoppers as more high-end retailers
further enhance Miami�s image. In West Miami, the $270 million, 1.4 million
square-foot Dolphin Mall opened in 2001 and includes 150 shopping, dining,
and entertainment outlets anchored by a 400,000 square-foot entertainment
center. In Coconut Grove, an additional $7 million office and retail expansion
of Cocowalk is currently underway and expected to be completed by late
2002. In Coral Gables, the Village of Merrick Park, an 850,000 square-foot
landmark mixed-use project anticipated to open in September 2002, is currently
being developed by The Rouse Company and is expected to include office
and residential components.
Current projections indicate that the Miami International Airport (MIA)
will handle more than 40 million passengers in the next several years.
In an effort to accommodate the anticipated increase in demand, MIA is
undergoing a nearly $2 billion expansion program, which includes a fourth
runway as well as north and south terminal expansions with total completion
anticipated by mid 2006. The 8,600-square foot runway is expected to increase
airfield capacity by 22% and is scheduled for completion in 2003. It is
anticipated that the plan will maintain MIA�s competitiveness with other
airports, alleviate congestion and facilitate passenger traffic through
the airport. Additional large-scale capital improvement plans for the Miami
International Airport are planned but may be deferred in response to a
decline in passenger traffic following 9/11.
In order to relieve congestion in MIA�s terminal roadways, as well as
increase curb capacity, there are plans to restrict access to the terminal
curb for all vehicles other than private automobiles and taxis. The Miami
Intermodal Center (MIC), therefore, is proposed to serve as a regional
transportation hub as well as an extension of MIA�s ground transportation
network. The MIC will accommodate courtesy vans, buses and limousines previously
destined for MIA�s terminal curb, thereby relieving approximately 30% of
MIA�s curb-front traffic. The MIC will also serve as an intermodal hub
for Amtrak, Tri-Rail, Metrorail, a proposed East-West rail line, buses,
taxis, and private automobiles. All modes will be connected to MIA via
an automated, fixed guideway transit system, the MIC/MIA Connector. The
MIC will also house selected airport landslide terminal functions, such
as ticketing and baggage service, and will accommodate the Airport/Seaport
Connector, providing premium rail service between MIA and the Port
of Miami.
Major Supply Changes
Given the amount of luxury hotel projects entering the Miami market,
many are concerned about Miami�s ability to absorb so many four-and five-star
rooms. Although developers expect that distinct sub-markets and unique
positioning will differentiate their products, it is more likely that such
increases in supply will have a dampening effect on the market. Furthermore,
luxury and first-class properties will be increasingly challenged due to
recent additions to supply, a greater inflexibility in minimizing overhead
to maintain service levels and the effect of consumers trading-down to
upscale and midscale hotels to decrease spending.
Among the most recent luxury developments in the Downtown Miami/Brickell
submarket are the $80 million, 300-room J.W. Marriott (October 2000), the
$100 million, 329-room Mandarin Oriental (December 2000) and the $34 million
renovation of the 639-room Inter-Continental Hotel. A $350 million Four
Seasons hotel is expected to open in late 2003. With 222 rooms, 176 condo
units and 84 condominium-hotel units, the property is being co-developed
by Millennium Partners and Terremark Group and is anticipated to be the
tallest building south of Atlanta and the tallest residential complex south
of New York City. In addition, the existing apartment complex of Dupont
Plaza Center, in the downtown area, is expected to be converted into a
146-unit Residence Inn by summer 2002. Plans are also underway to upgrade
the office component of Dupont Plaza as Class B and reposition and re-brand
the existing 297 hotel rooms. Lionstone Hotels and Resorts, the current
owners, plan to develop a travel and trade center in the renovated complex
that would centralize foreign consulates, chambers of commerce and trade
shows.
On nearby Watson Island, opposite Parrot Jungle�s new home, plans for
a $281 million upscale mixed-use development are underway. The project
is anticipated to include two luxury hotels, a marina, an open-air fish
market and ancillary restaurant and retail facilities.
The $176 million, 352-room Ritz-Carlton located on Key Biscayne opened
in July 2001 complementing the 188-unit condominium-hotel, while the 115-room
Ritz-Carlton in Coconut Grove is anticipated to open in April 2002 along
with the Residences at Ritz-Carlton, a 175-unit luxury condominium project.
The condominium-hotel niche has proven to be a popular concept for the
Coconut Grove area, with the luxury $70 million, 224-condominium-hotel
Sonesta Mutiny Park anticipated to open in April 2002.
As a result of the airport expansion and development of the Miami Intermodal
Center, several hotel properties were acquired and permanently closed,
resulting in a decline of approximately 830 rooms in hotel inventory. While
the airport area has experienced a surge in limited service and extended
stay hotel developments in recent years, several full-service hotel projects
are in early development stages. Starwood Hotels & Resorts has been
in discussions with developers since early 1999 to develop a hotel in the
airport area. Reportedly, Starwood and HI Development were in discussions
to convert the existing 260-room Miami International Airport Hotel to a
Sheraton property. The project is expected to include an additional tower
containing 200 rooms; formal plans, however, are still on hold. In addition,
a possible hotel site near the Marriott Complex on Le Jeune Road for a
450-room Sheraton is rumored.
Political/Economic/Legal Changes
The Elian Gonzalez saga put Miami in the world spotlight for a five-month
period in 2000 and revived local friction over the Cuba ordinance � a legislation
that bars county support for companies that have involvement with Cuba.
The resulting turmoil at city hall was one of the factors that led to the
lost opportunity to host the inaugural Latin Grammy�s music awards to the
city of Los Angeles in 2000. A strong lobbying campaign by influential
activists brought the Latin Grammy�s to Miami in 2001, only to learn three
weeks before the event that the organizers decided to take the venue back
to L.A. due to safety concerns for attendees and performers. This major
blow to Miami was estimated to have a direct impact on the economy of approximately
$35 million, while the loss of 15,000 visitors and transmission to over
800 million viewers in over 120 countries may have wider repercussions
for the local lodging industry.
Hotels in Miami Beach are still finding themselves in an emergency mode
in the short term, leading to slashed rates of over 50% to entice Florida
residents to take a vacation close to home. Given the area�s heavy reliance
on tourism and convention activity, as well as high levels of international
visitors, the lodging market�s recovery in 2002 may move at a slightly
slower pace as compared with the overall state and U.S. lodging markets.
Major Demand Changes
With approximately 96% of the area�s visitors arriving by air, Miami
Beach�s lodging industry has continued to fare well below state and U.S.
levels in the wake of 9/11. The Greater Miami Convention and Visitors Bureau
("GMCVB") estimates a loss of approximately $750 million in tourism-related
business through November 2001 as a direct result of the terrorist attacks,
despite aggressive marketing campaigns. The GMCVB recorded seven major
meeting cancellations after 9/11, resulting in a loss of approximately
$3.9 million in revenues; these seven events have not been rebooked. The
cancellation of a leading international art show, Art Basel, which hosts
over 1,000 artists from 150 galleries worldwide, presented a major loss
for the area in December 2001. Fortunately, the show has been rescheduled
for December 2002. While the outlook for convention bookings remains cautiously
optimistic for 2002, attrition rates are expected to range from 10% to
20%. The county is also currently scrutinizing its fragmented inventory
of convention space and formulating a strategy to become more competitive,
although no specific plans have been announced.
In response to the recent terrorist attacks, the GMCVB is attempting
to entice travelers by appealing to them on an emotional level with the
roll out of the $2.2 million �What Makes You Happy� campaign, offering
special hotel rates and encouraging nearby drive-to markets to vacation
close to home. Severe drops in domestic and international air travel due
to a combination of corporate belt-tightening and fear of flying will continue
to pose threats to the tourism campaign. Overall visitation is expected
to decline between 12% and 15% in the first quarter of 2002, the peak of
Miami Beach�s tourist season.
Despite these events, the revitalization of South Beach continues to
be a major focus and numerous luxury hotel and residential projects are
underway, as well as supporting retail and office developments. While
Miami Beach has primarily been a leisure destination, it has attracted
several information technology companies in recent years. Despite several
Internet companies going bust, South Beach, which has been referred to
as Silicon Beach, remains an e-commerce hub for Internet companies serving
the Americas, including YupiMSN.com and Fiera.com. The area is also becoming
increasingly popular for entertainment companies focusing on Latin America,
as well as art-based tourism and conventions.
Major Supply Changes
Although the Miami Beach lodging market commands a $60 average daily
rate premium over Miami, the area is concerned about the depth of demand
willing to pay high prices given the wave of luxury hotel projects entering
the market. No one knows for sure how dramatic the impact will be in the
near term, particularly during the summer months when every hotelier slashes
rates to capture visitors; however, the surge of upscale commercial, retail
and recreational development bodes well for the area�s overall lodging
demand in the long term.
Among the most recent upscale developments in Miami Beach are the 324-room
Shore Club (July 2001), the 385-room Ritz-Carlton, the planned 200-room
W Hotel by Starwood and the 90-room Setai. These projects involve extensive
redevelopment efforts to blend the extravagance of luxury hotels with the
sleek art-deco style of South Beach. Another proposed entry to the South
Beach luxury set, The Victor, a historic Art-Deco style hotel, is currently
in the planning stages by ZOM properties to be developed into a luxury
hotel adjacent to Gianni Versace�s former mansion. Casa Casaurina, as the
mansion is known, will also have its share of renovations. Plans are to
make the building more public by turning it into a 15-suite, �six-star�
hotel or fractional ownership property. Following a $100 million renovation
and expansion of the DiLido Hotel, originally constructed in 1953, the
Ritz-Carlton, located on the same block of Collins Avenue as the stylish
Delano Hotel, is scheduled to open in August 2002. Within one block of
the Ritz-Carlton, a joint venture between Starwood Hotels and Resorts and
Ritz Plaza Associates will develop a 200-room W Hotel, also opening in
late 2002. Just a few blocks north of The Shore Club is The Setai, a $120
million, 90-room, all-suite resort, being developed by Adrian Zecha,
founder of Aman Resorts, expected to open in early 2003.
Other well-established hotel chains are also finding Miami Beach a desirable
market. In October 2000, Marriott opened its first resort in South Beach
along Ocean Drive. In addition, the 422-room Royal Palm Crowne Plaza, located
adjacent to the Loews Miami Beach, is anticipated to open in February 2002,
despite numerous construction delays.
The Westin Diplomat Resort & Spa in nearby Hollywood is expected
to present a
possible threat to several group hotels on Miami Beach. Featuring
998 rooms and over 200,000 square feet of meeting space, the property opened
in January 2002. In order to maintain their competitive posture in the
midst of significant new supply, existing properties in Miami Beach have
completed major renovations. The historic landmark Eden Roc Resort &
Spa underwent a $26 million upgrade and repositioning as a Renaissance
property. Sheraton Bal Harbour Beach Resort also completed an $11 million
renovation while the Turnberry Isle Resort & Club recently added a
25,000-square foot spa with a $10 million price tag. Furthermore, Roney
Palace Resort and Spa completed a $25 million renovation and redevelopment
of its 5.5 acre site.
In addition to these large-scale and chain-affiliated projects, independent
boutique hotels are flourishing in South Beach and are contributing to
the supply increase in the area. Given the high barriers to entry in this
market, these properties are typically adaptive reuses.
Recent reopenings of boutique hotels within the past few years include
the Townhouse, Whitelaw, Mercury, Abbey, Wave, and Crescent. The
242-room, boutique style Miami Beach Ocean Resort also underwent a $5 million
renovation and converted to The Palms in late 2001. In addition, The Arden
Group recently purchased the Savoy Hotel for $18 million; the property
is expected to be redeveloped and operated by S&S Hotel Management.
The Fontainebleau Hilton and Turnberry Associates recently announced plans
to build The Tower Residences at the Fontainebleau, a condo-minium-hotel
on the south end of the 18-acre property. The new $200 million, 36-story
project will feature 464 residences and is scheduled to open in December
2004. In South Beach, the 109-unit Bentley Beach condominium-hotel is anticipated
to open in June 2002. Another South Beach development, the De Soleil South
Beach, an 80-unit project located on Ocean Drive between 14th and 15th
Street, is expected to open in the spring of 2003. Condominium-hotel projects
are also being developed in Sunny Isles, including the 166-unit Ocean Point
(January 2001) and the 381-unit Trump International Beach Resort, managed
by Sonesta International Hotels, anticipated to open in September 2003.
In addition, Acqualina Ocean Resort & Residences, a 50-unit luxury
condominium-hotel and 65-room hotel to be managed by Rosewood, is anticipated
to open in late 2003.
Political/Economic/Legal Changes
Despite the revitalization efforts in Miami Beach, the city is struggling
to keep up with the growth in the immediate area. Traffic congestion and
lack of parking continue to be problems for both locals and incoming tourists.
As visitation and new developments along the skyline are expected to increase
in the coming years, these issues are expected to aggravate and negatively
impact the quality of life of residents. In addition, the city�s inability
to control and comfortably accommodate visitor attendance during large
celebrations deserve particular attention by city officials. Furthermore,
the results of recent mayoral elections in Miami Beach may limit prospects
for new development.
The events of 9/11 contributed to declines of approximately 16% in occupied
room nights and 4% in average daily rate for Fort Lauderdale during the
last quarter of 2001 when compared to the same period in 2000, as leisure
and group demand diminished. Despite this tough period, the city
remains committed to undergo a dramatic facelift to enhance its image as
a vibrant commercial city and upscale South Florida vacation destination.
Upcoming commercial, infrastructure and recreational developments in Fort
Lauderdale are expected to contribute to healthy lodging demand in the
future, although an estimated 6% increase in new supply in 2002 is anticipated
to negatively impact occupancies.
Major Demand Changes
Following the sudden drop of tourism traffic in the wake of the 9/11
attacks, hospitality and political leaders responded by launching multi-million
dollar marketing programs. The Greater Ft. Lauderdale Convention &
Visitors Bureau initiated a multi-faceted marketing initiative directed
primarily at Florida encouraging people within driving distance to vacation
in South Florida.
Despite monthly declines in passenger traffic of 26%, 17% and 15% between
September and November 2001 respectively, year to date figures through
November at Fort Lauderdale/Hollywood International Airport indicated a
5% increase in demand relative to the same period in 2000. An increase
in airlift capacity by Continental, JetBlue, Northwest and Spirit contributed
to the rise in demand, bringing the total number of passengers through
November to nearly 15.1 million. Domestic traffic exhibited positive growth
of 6%, while international passenger traffic declined approximately 3%
over the prior year. The city�s airport continues to succeed as a convenient
and often less expensive alternative to the more congested Miami International
Airport. The heavy presence of low-cost carriers, which capture more than
25% of the market, also makes this area popular among domestic tourists.
Fort Lauderdale/Hollywood International Airport is in the midst of a $655
million expansion program, which includes additional gates within the terminal
complex, an extension of the runway, two additional parking garages, as
well as access improvements. An additional nine-gate concourse in the new
terminal is expected to be completed by late 2002.
An expansion of 50,000 square feet of exhibit space at the Broward County
Convention Center (BCCC) is currently underway, bringing total exhibit
space to 230,000 square feet. With an expected delivery date of February
2002, the increase in meeting capacity is expected to enable the city to
compete more effectively among other destinations for trade show and association
group demand.
Major Supply Changes
Similar to its neighbor to the south, Fort Lauderdale is anticipated
to experience a surge in new luxury hotel supply over the next few years.
Ground was broken for Florida�s first St. Regis Hotel & Residences
in January 2002 along Ft. Lauderdale Beach Boulevard. This $135 million,
197-unit beachfront project is scheduled for com-pletion in late 2003 and
will also include penthouse residences and vacation ownership units. Directly
to the north of The St. Regis, at Terramar Street, a 124-unit luxury condominium-hotel,
The Atlantic, is currently planned and is expected to begin construction
in June 2002 and be completed in late 2003. Plans for a proposed Club Regent,
a 34-unit luxury fractional ownership property located to the south of
The St. Regis, on Seabreeze Boulevard, were canceled. The developer
is planning to develop an 81-unit luxury condominium-hotel and is expected
to begin construction in April 2002, with completion set for late 2003.
On North Atlantic Boulevard, the $100 million Costa Dorada, a 278-unit
condominium hotel, is slated to begin construction in September 2002 and
is expected to open in early 2004. Plans have also been unveiled for The
Capri, a $150 million resort, which is scheduled to commence construction
in late 2002 with completion in early 2004. The 346-room resort, which
is also expected to include an additional 171 timeshare units, is reportedly
in management negotiations with Regent Hotels.
In conjunction with the BCCC expansion, Peebles Atlantic Development
Corporation formed a partnership with Wyndham International to develop
the $70 million, 506-unit Wyndham Fort Lauderdale Hotel. Disagreements
between the development company and Broward County officials over the terms
of the ground lease, however, terminated negotiations between the two parties
and forced Wyndham to withdraw its support for the project. Located within
two blocks of the BCCC is the $37 million, 233-room Renaissance Fort Lauderdale,
which opened in June 2001. In downtown Fort Lauderdale, a new $15 million,
156-room Hampton Inn opened in January 2002. The area will also welcome
the expansion of the landmark Riverside Hotel with an additional 116 rooms,
increasing the hotel�s inventory to 217 rooms by March 2002.
Two major resort projects are currently underway in nearby Hollywood.
After experiencing construction delays and management turnover, the 998-room
Westin Diplomat Resort & Spa opened in January 2002. With more than
200,000 square feet of meeting space, golf facilities, retail outlets and
spa, the Diplomat is expected to compete with South Florida�s premier destination
resorts. Its sister property, the Diplomat Country Club & Spa, opened
in March 2000 just across the street from the Westin and became a member
of Starwood�s Luxury Collection. The second Hollywood project is the Seminole
Hard Rock Hotel & Resort, which is located on tribal land and currently
under construction. The $300 million complex is expected to include a 750-room
hotel, a health spa, extensive lakeside beach club, gaming facilities,
retail/entertainment complex and a Hard Rock Café restaurant.
Completion is scheduled for late 2003.
A surge in full-service hotel development within Fort Lauderdale�s suburbs
is also occurring. The newest addition to the market is a 250-room Crowne
Plaza Hotel in Sunrise, which opened in December 2001 while the 250-room
Renaissance Hotel Plantation is expected to open in September 2002. Marriott�s
second hotel in Plantation, the 250-room Marriott at Sawgrass, located
near the National Car Rental Center and Sawgrass Mills, began construction
in June 2001 and is scheduled for completion in early 2003.
In order to maintain their competitive posture during significant supply
additions, existing properties are undergoing major renovations. The Holiday
Inn Plantation/Sawgrass completed a $5 million renovation in April 2001.
The Marriott Fort Lauderdale North recently upgraded amenities, improved
guest services, and refurbished guestrooms and meeting space at a cost
of $8.5 million. In Fort Lauderdale Beach, the Radisson Bahia Mar Beach
Resort underwent a major renovation of its rooms in February 2001 while
the Marriott Harbor Beach Resort recently completed the second phase of
a $36 million refurbishment project. The resort�s new $8 million, 22,000-square
foot spa opened in June 2001. The Pelican Beach Resort, located in North
Fort Lauderdale Beach, is expected to demolish eight of its nine aging
buildings to make way for a new 168-room oceanfront hotel. Construction
is scheduled for August 2002 and inauguration planned for late 2003. Other
hotels, such as the Sunrise Hilton, which built a professional soccer field
20 yards from its main entrance, expect to maintain their competitiveness
by capitalizing on niche markets.
Political/Economic/Legal Changes
Growth in western Broward has boomed throughout the 1990s, as businesses
and residents have flocked to the new suburbs, setting off a construction
boom that has helped drive the metro area�s gains. The Eastward Ho! Regional
Planning Movement is attempting to reduce sprawl, preserve rapidly vanishing
green space and protect the Everglades by encouraging high-density development
in urban areas. Fort Lauderdale�s downtown area continues to undergo a
major transformation to an urban center for residents to live, work, and
play. The success of Las Olas Boulevard started the current development
scramble and has encouraged developers of other projects to move forward.
With a surge of high-rise, upscale residential projects under construction,
the lack of mass transit options for the area � the cornerstone for urban
revitalization � remains a concern.
Orlando�s position as a successful leisure and convention destination,
with one of the largest hotel inventories in the nation, was significantly
challenged by the 9/11 events, lower consumer spending and cuts in corporate
travel during the latter portion of 2001. Occupancy in Orlando plummeted
by 24% in October and November 2001, compared to the same period in 2000,
while Disney park attendance reportedly dropped by 25%. Given recent signs
of positive improvement in the U.S. economy, however, hoteliers are predicting
slow but continued recovery of Orlando�s lodging industry in 2002.
Major Demand Changes
Airport passenger traffic was down a slim 5% for the year through August
2001, but in September and October these figures dropped significantly
to 32% and 23%, respectively. In response to lower levels of visitation
and occupancy declines of 24% during the latter part of the year, theme
parks and lodging facilities began regional marketing campaigns to attract
visitors within driving distance of Orlando in hopes
of combating the decline in air travel. These campaigns helped boost
visitation levels during the month of December. Since then, passenger traffic
and hotel occupancy declines have become less severe �occupancies declined
by 18% and 9% during the last two weeks of December compared to the same
time in 2000.
After breaking ground in March 2000, the $748 million expansion of the
Orange County Convention Center (the OCCC) is anticipated to add approximately
one million square feet of exhibit space, increasing the facility�s size
to 2.1 million square feet by October 2003. The expansion site is located
across International Drive and both buildings will be connected through
an enclosed, air-conditioned walkway with a people-mover. Despite declines
in convention attendance of approximately 3% pre 9/11 and 16% post 9/11,
the OCCC�s expansion plans continue as scheduled. It is anticipated that
in 2005, the first full calendar year following the completion of the OCCC�s
expansion, attendance will increase by 56% over 2002 levels, according
to the OCCC. The OCCC estimates that convention attendance will be down
by 15% during the first quarter of 2002, improving gradually throughout
the remainder of the year.
Disney World�s year long celebration of the 100th anniversary of Walt
Disney�s birth started in October of 2001 and will include special events,
new attractions and live entertainment. These special events and attractions
are anticipated to generate increased media awareness for the parks to
boost demand. In fact, two of its parks, Magic Kingdom and EPCOT Center,
reached maximum capacity during the December 2001 holiday season.
Disney World will be adding a new attraction in 2003. The Space Pavilion
at EPCOT Center will feature a series of interactive exhibits and space
exploration-themed shows. The motion-simulator ride will be based on the
equipment that NASA astronauts use to prepare for space flights. Details
of the project are still being finalized but Disney is moving forward with
the $200 million project and has already begun preliminary work inside
the Horizons Pavilion at Epcot.
Plans are still underway to build a World Expo Center in Osceola County,
with an estimated opening date of 2005. After the original developer was
unable to move forward with the project, the county re-bid the project
and the developers of the Gaylord Palms Hotel, Xentury City, plan to place
a bid. Once built, the World Expo Center is anticipated to generate additional
convention and group demand for the Orlando area.
Major Supply Changes
Prior to 9/11, the Orlando lodging sector responded to increasing room
demand by aggressively adding hotel rooms, and observed inventory increases
of approximately 26% between 1995 and 2000.
Approximately 3,400 additional rooms were added in 2001 for a total
of 105,800 rooms, a 3% increase over 2000. Between 2002 and 2005, approximately
10,800 rooms are anticipated to enter the market, bringing Orlando�s supply
to 116,600 rooms, a 10% increase. Limited-service hotels comprise 14% of
this pipeline, which does not include hotel projects placed on hold or
rumored.
In Kissimmee, the Gaylord Palms Hotel, formerly known as the Opryland
Florida, located two miles from the proposed World Expo Center, opened
its doors ahead of schedule in January 2002. The $450 million hotel features
1,406 rooms on 68 acres and approximately 400,000 square feet of meeting
space, including a 178,000-square foot exhibition hall. Developers expect
occupancy in the first year to reach approximately 60%, largely comprised
of convention and group business. A third Loews property at Universal Studios,
the 1,000-room Royal Pacific Resort, is anticipated to open in July 2002.
Orlando�s Grand Lakes Resort, along John Young Parkway, is under construction
and will feature a 584-room Ritz-Carlton Hotel and a 1,000-room JW Marriott
Hotel, both of which are expected to open in July 2003. Four Seasons is
reportedly also looking to make an entry in the local market.
The $700 million, 1,200-acre Champions Gate master-planned resort development
adjacent to Celebration, including a 730-room Omni Hotel, was delayed due
to slower economic trends. The Omni Hotel will reportedly feature 80,000
square feet of meeting space and is now expected to open in early 2004.
Another major planned community, the Reunion Resort and Club, has plans
for up to 3,000 hotel rooms on its 2,300-acre site, in addition to 5,000
resort homes, three golf courses, an equestrian center and other recreational
facilities to be delivered in 2003.
Hyatt Hotels acquired land in the vicinity of the OCCC for a 1,500-room
hotel with a tentative opening date in 2005. Also adjacent to the Center,
Hilton Hotels Corporation has plans to build a 1,200-room hotel on land
it purchased from Universal Orlando. The proposed Hilton expects to offer
100,000 square feet of meeting space. Construction was expected to commence
in early 2002, however, the project was placed on hold as a result of unfavorable
market conditions.
Hotelier Harris Rosen acquired from Universal Studios a $30 million,
230-acre site near the Bee Line Expressway, to build a 1,500-room convention
hotel, with a golf course and 250,000 square feet of meeting space. Construction
is expected to start in early 2003, with the hotel opening in 2005. Development
of Disney�s 5,760-room economy-style Pop Century Hotel was indefinitely
postponed following the events of 9/11.
The 2,267-room Swan and Dolphin hotels are undergoing a $75 million
expansion and enhancement project to be completed in the fall of 2002,
which includes the addition of 79,000 square feet of meeting space to the
Swan property. The two hotels� exhibition space will also be expanded from
61,000 to 111,000 square feet, and the properties are upgrading their facilities
to become more competitive with
new group and convention-oriented hotel supply anticipated to come
on line in the next three years.
Political/Economic/Legal Changes
Despite recent declines in lodging industry performance, the majority
of Orlando�s service industry jobs have been saved and local county governments
as well as tourism-related entities have approved millions of dollars for
emergency marketing spending. Recent economic changes, however, indicate
that Orange and Osceola counties are especially vulnerable to declines
in this tourism-based economy. Walt Disney World cut 4,000 jobs and reduced
work schedules for 40,000 employees.
There are discussions taking place regarding possible increases in
the tourist bed tax and a change in Florida State law to use a portion
of the tax proceeds to spur economic development and to further diversify
the local economy.
A mid-term solution to traffic congestion is becoming increasingly important.
New transportation improvement projects, totaling over $3 billion, are
currently being discussed and involve the widening of Interstate 4 through
Orange, Seminole, and Osceola counties, the addition of high-occupancy
vehicle and possibly toll lanes, as well as a new rail system. Passenger
traffic at the Orlando International Airport
surpassed the 30 million mark in 2000 and the airport is now completing
a $1.2 billion expansion program. Despite the recent impact of 9/11 events
on the aviation industry, airlift capacity improvements are crucial to
sustain long-term tourism and business growth.
While hotel demand growth outpaced supply growth in 2000, the events
of 9/11 resulted in declines in hotel demand during the latter portion
of 2001, while supply remained relatively stable. Compared to lodging activity
in other Florida markets, however, Tampa was not as adversely impacted
during the 2001 calendar year. More than 5,000 new hotel rooms are in the
pipeline for the next three years; the majority of projects are rumored
or in the early planning stages. Hotel occupancies are anticipated to improve
in the third quarter of 2002 and newly built shopping malls and entertainment
complexes are expected to contribute to an increase in areawide lodging
demand.
Major Demand Changes
Tampa has observed a recent boom in shopping mall, retail and entertainment
complex construction. Local hoteliers expect new shopping and entertainment
centers to increase local hotel demand from tourists extending their stay
in Central Florida to shop after trips to Disney World and the west coast
beaches. In Ybor City, Steiner & Associates opened Centro Ybor, a $45
million, 210,000-square foot
retail and entertainment complex with upscale shops, restaurants, a
20- screen Muvico Movie Theater, Game Works and a comedy club. The company
expects the new mall to receive three million visitors per year, including
non-regional tourists in the area visiting other attractions.
The Tampa Convention Center re-adapted its 600,000 square foot facility
to accommodate 36 breakout rooms, from the existing 18, through the reconfiguration
of storage and office space. Following the $6 million renovation project,
completed in October 2001, the Center now offers 200,000 square feet of
exhibit space and 85,000 square feet of meeting space. The increase in
the number of breakout rooms is
expected to improve the Convention Center�s ability to accommodate
smaller groups, therefore generating more convention activity to the area.
In 2000, Tampa hosted 108,000 convention delegates, while in 2001, convention
attendance increased by 80% to 194,000, as a result of the Super Bowl.
Annual passenger traffic at the Port of Tampa reached 519,000 in 2001,
up 13% from 2000, as a result, in part, of two new cruise ships, the Royal
Caribbean Rhapsody and the Celebrity Venus, which began sailing in the
latter part of the year. Passenger volume in 2002 is expected to further
increase to approximately 600,000, according to the Port Authority. As
most cruise line visitors require overnight accommodation prior to departure,
hotel demand is expected to be positively affected.
Major Supply Changes
A number of full-service hotels are currently underway in the Greater
Tampa area. Westin Hotels & Resorts unveiled plans for a 300-room luxury
hotel scheduled to open in mid-2004 at Tampa Bay I, a $200 million office
and retail center planned for Interstate 275 and Dale Mabry Highway. Despite
the events of 9/11, the upscale 1.2 million-square foot International Plaza
shopping mall in the Westshore business district opened in mid-September
2001. The $200 million project was developed by a Michigan-based REIT and
is anticipated to further include a four-star hotel with approximately
300 rooms and a target opening date in 2003. Negotiations are still underway
to select a hotel operator. In the meantime, the mall has been attracting
out of town visitors and offering hotel packages on its Internet site.
The Tampa Port Authority has a master-plan development to enhance dockside
attractions for visitors and the local community. The Shops at Channelside,
comprising the first phase of the plan, are a joint development of the
Hogan Group and Orix Corporation and opened in the spring of 2001. The
urban entertainment center is a 230,000 square foot, $35 million complex,
adjacent to the Florida Aquarium and cruise terminal. The open mall includes
a nine-theater movie
complex, a number of specialty restaurants, and retail. The master
plan further includes the addition of three more cruise terminals (including
Cruise Terminal 3 which is already under construction), an expansion of
the Tampa Florida Aquarium and a hotel with up to 1,000 rooms and meeting
space. According to the Port Authority, there are no significant negotiations
taking place between the Port and a possible developer for the hotel site
at this time. The entire plan for the area will take five to 10 years to
implement.
The Tampa Bay area�s newest hotel is the $130 million, 266-room luxury
waterfront Ritz-Carlton in Sarasota, which opened in November 2001. The
hotel features 18,000 square feet of meeting space and $48 million condominium
units. The hotel development triggered $1 billion in real estate and infrastructure
construction and redevelopment in downtown Sarasota and along the waterfront.
The hotel plans to further add a 15,000-square foot spa and private beach
club in the fall of 2002.
A second luxury hotel is proposed as part of an $80 million redevelopment
project including a 17-story luxury condominium tower, upscale retail and
an 86-room luxury hotel at the intersection of Drew Street and Osceola
Avenue, in Clearwater. Construction may start in 2003, depending on economic
conditions at the time.
Additional new supply in the Greater Tampa area includes a 160-suite
Residence Inn by the McKibbon Brothers, which opened in the Westshore business
district across from the International Plaza mall in November 2001. Furthermore,
a 205-room Radisson Hotel and Conference Center in St. Petersburg and a
115-room Hilton Garden Inn in the Sarasota-Brandenton International Airport
also opened in December 2001.
In addition to the proposed full-service hotel supply, several Microtel
Inn & Suites, Holiday Inn Express & Suites, Bradbury Suites, Marriott
limited-service products, Wingate Inn and Hilton Garden Inn properties
are proposed in the Greater Tampa area to be developed in the next three
years. In the all-suite segment, Matrix Lodging plans to launch a new hotel
concept, eSuites, in 2002. One of nine initial 150-unit technology-oriented
eSuite hotels is expected to be built in Tampa.
Political/Economic/Legal Changes
Tampa is one of the top cyber cities in the country and ranks fifth
among the top cities in the nation for high-tech jobs. It is estimated
that approximately 1,600 high-tech businesses have settled in the Tampa
Bay area. Although at a slower pace than in past years, high-tech companies
continued to relocate to Tampa and expand existing facilities in 2001.
Tampa�s recognition as the heart of the state�s high-tech
corridor significantly contributes to the immediate area�s overall
economic development.
Tampa International Airport is a fast growing airport handling more
than 16 million passengers per year. Prior to 9/11, airport passenger activity
was up by 5% in 2001 compared to the prior year. Following the terrorist
events, however, the number of enplaned and deplaned passengers experienced
declines ranging anywhere from 13% to 27% for the period between September
and December 2001. Despite the
recent decline in passenger activity, Tampa International Airport is
undergoing a five-year, $400 million expansion project to accommodate an
increasing number of passengers in the mid- to long-term, which includes
the renovation and expansion of two airside terminals, the addition of
aircraft parking, the refurbishment of ticketing areas, the construction
of a 2,100-car passenger parking lot, the upgrade of the monorail system
and a $7 million renovation of the Airport Marriott Hotel. Local airport
authorities expect the expanded airport to be capable of supporting growing
passenger traffic resulting from increased business and tourism travel
to the area. It is anticipated that construction and renovations will be
completed by 2005.
Daytona Beach
Traditionally known as the premier racing destination along Florida�s
east coast, Daytona is undergoing the biggest tourism expansion in its
history and was fortunate enough to be one of the few markets throughout
the state to be only marginally impacted by the events of 9/11. According
to Mid-Florida Marketing and Research, Inc., occupancy in September following
the attacks dropped approximately five points to 48% compared to the same
period during the prior year. While occupancy remained fairly stable
for the remainder of 2001, average room rates surprisingly increased by
as much as 9%. ADRs in November, for example, increased from $64 in 2000
to approximately $70 in 2001.
This stellar performance -relative to other destinations in Florida
and considering the impact of 9/11 throughout the state- was largely attributed
to the drive-in nature of this market. It is estimated that approximately
85% of visitors drive to Daytona, a figure that is expected to remain stable
in the near term due to limited airlift to the city � the only airline
carrier to now service Daytona is Delta Airlines, after Continental Airlines
decided to cancel its flights in mid-2001. Another factor that helped Daytona
post better-than-anticipated performance in 2001 was that hotel owners
avoided heavy rate discounting by attracting higher paying visitors who
would normally fly to other destinations but opted to drive to Daytona
as a result of
9/11 events. For 2002, general managers and other lodging professionals
expect occupancy in Daytona to recover within the first six months and
room rates to show positive growth throughout the year.
Daytona observed in 2001 the construction of the $250 million Ocean
Walk Village redevelopment project, which includes upscale hotels, boutiques,
restaurants, and shopping. The project is expected to reshape the city
as an attractive convention destination and a more upscale leisure alternative.
The 300-room Ocean Walk Resort at the Village, which opened in mid-2001,
is Daytona�s newest oceanfront condominium-hotel. Significant renovations
underway include the $37 million refurbishment of the Plaza Resort and
Spa, which will include the renovation of its 322 rooms and public areas
and an increase of 32,000 square feet in meeting space, anticipated to
be completed in early 2002. Another important project, the $53 million,
310-room expansion of the Adam�s Mark Hotel, planned for early 2002,
is expected to add 35,000 feet of new meeting space and increase the hotel�s
inventory from 436 to 746 guestrooms. Plans are also underway to break
ground on a second phase of the Ocean Walk Resort in 2002, which will feature
264 additional units in a $40 million tower.
Greater Naples and Marco Island
With the most golf holes per capita and ranking among the Top 25 art
markets in the nation, Collier County is recognized as one of the premier
resort destinations on the Gulf Coast of Florida, boasting renowned hotels
such as the 463-room, five-star, five-diamond Ritz-Carlton Naples and the
474-room Registry Resort. Given that the area is a high-end golf and leisure
destination comprised mostly of affluent, fly-in visitors with substantial
discretionary income, this market was significantly impacted by the events
of 9/11, as its customer base dramatically cancelled its travel plans after
the attacks. According to Research Data Services, occupancy in Collier
County for September 2001 declined significantly to 39% from 59% the previous
year while direct visitor expenditures were just over $8 million, a 36%
drop compared to 2000 levels. Hotel owners are concerned that warmer weather
in the Northeast, a shorter winter season due to Easter Holidays occurring
earlier this year in late March and a slower booking pace from Canadian
and European visitors may further delay the area�s recovery in 2002.
In terms of development, Naples is yet another city in the state to
be placed under a moratorium on new construction as a result of fears of
unmanaged growth. Officials are concerned that the area may grow in a disorganized
fashion and have issued restrictions on land use in Naples, including hotel
projects, to allow time for officials to dialogue with landowners, developers,
and environmental groups and identify
better ways to control urban sprawl and preserve agriculture and the
environment. This measure, however, only impacts future projects and is
not expected to affect several hotels that are already under construction.
In 2001, Naples welcomed the
456-room Hyatt Regency Coconut Point, which opened in October and a
51,000 square foot spa at the Ritz-Carlton Naples. Several renovations
were also completed such as the refurbishment of 63 suites at the Edgewater
Beach Hotel and the redecoration of 256 rooms at the Naples Beach Hotel
and Golf Club. Neighboring Marco Island also welcomed the luxurious Marco
Beach Ocean Resort in December, which features 103 one- and two-bedroom
suites, a full-service spa and approximately 12,000 square feet of meeting
space.
Major developments for 2002 include the opening of the $75 million Ritz-Carlton
Golf Resort, which features 295 rooms overlooking a 36-hole, Greg Norman
golf course and a signature 18-hole putting green, the $45 million renovation
of the 189-room La Playa Beach and Golf Resort and the introduction of
a 124-room Four Points Sheraton in downtown Naples. The Marco Island Marriott
Resort and Golf Club is expected to launch a major $43 million refurbishment
project to be completed by mid-2003, which will include renovating all
of its guestrooms, adding a full service spa, 10,000 square feet of meeting
space and renovating its 18-hole golf course. In Naples, the Inn on Fifth
will also undergo a $700,000 renovation project to upgrade its guestrooms
and public areas.
Although September is typically considered a slow period for hotel owners
in the Florida Keys (The Keys), the events of 9/11 impacted visitation
to the region causing occupancy to decrease by as much as 10% for the same
period during the prior year. Lodging performance was further affected
in November 2001 due to concerns that Hurricane Michelle could hit The
Keys, forcing city officials to order a mandatory
evacuation and to postpone the final race of the Powerboat World Championship.
Although the lodging sector showed some signs of recovery during the last
two weeks of the year � posting occupancies in the high eighties � this
demand came at a high price to hoteliers, as they were required to deeply
discount room rates to lure drive-in visitors.
Given the drive-in nature of The Keys� market, lodging professionals
are banking on increased levels of in-state visitors to help support occupancy
levels in 2002, although this demand is anticipated to come in at reduced
rates. Recent meetings between OPEC members, however, are signaling a possible
nationwide increase in gasoline prices, which may have a negative impact
in the area as Floridians may decrease vacation travel within the state.
In general, 2002 is expected to be a challenging year for The Keys. Hotel
owners hope that increasing consumer confidence as a result of improvements
in the economy and last-minute bookings will improve the sector�s performance
by third-quarter 2002.
Fortunately for The Keys, the area has only experienced a limited amount
of new development in recent years � preventing occupancies from further
decreasing � as a result of a construction moratorium imposed by authorities
due to their concerns about the appropriateness of evacuation routes should
a natural disaster strike.
The last major new hotel development in the area was the construction
of the 216-room full-service Grand Key Resort in August 2000. That same
year in March, the 74-room Hampton Inn in Marathon Key opened its doors
and in July, the Econolodge in Key West was repositioned as a Radisson
Hotel. Other recent additions to the area include the development of 247
villa units at Hawks Cay Resort,
which has been phased over the past three years. The resort also added
15,000 square feet of meeting space in 2001 and now features one of the
largest ballrooms in the region. Cheeca Lodge, a 203-room property built
in 1946 and affiliated with Small Luxury Hotels of the World, also recently
completed a 5,200 square-foot spa.
Given the moratorium on new construction, The Keys experienced a wave
of repositionings and limited new development in 2001. The Holiday Inn
La Concha, for example, was repositioned as a Crowne Plaza in January.
The Howard Johnson, which remained closed for over two years, became the
64-room Courtyard Key West Waterfront in May after extensive renovations,
while the Ramada Hotel was also repositioned as the 104-room Courtyard
Key West By-the-Sea. The pipeline for 2002
looks narrow, as the only major development in the region is a rumored
timeshare development by Spottswood Companies. The lack of significant
new supply is anticipated to accelerate the speed of recovery for The Keys.
Jacksonville�s $2.8 billion tourism economy was particularly affected
by the events of 9/11. For the past few years, the city has worked hard
to change its image and become a more attractive convention destination.
This stronger reliance on the group and meetings segment and the heavy
cancellations that occurred post 9/11, however, resulted in losses of as
much as $28 million according to the Convention and Visitors Bureau. Suffering
from a retraction in corporate travel expenditures, the
events of 9/11 further exacerbated declining occupancies due to the
city�s dependence on the group and meeting segment. In 2002, hotel owners
expect the booking pace to pick up and meeting planners to rebook meetings
and conventions. Overall, the city is expected to observe some signs of
recovery by mid-2002.
For the past three decades, Jacksonville has not experienced major hotel
developments in or around downtown. This trend, however, is being reversed
as the city welcomed a 966-room Adam�s Mark Hotel in February 2001. The
$126 million project is one of the largest meeting hotels in Northeast
Florida and should become the center-piece for the city�s plans to attract
larger conventions and become known as a meetings destination. The new
development is also expected to serve as the catalyst for several new construction
projects and corporate relocations to the downtown area. According
to the Convention and Visitors Bureau, in addition to the Adam�s Mark project,
the city observed the development of approximately 605 hotel rooms in 2001,
driven primarily by limited service and midscale properties. This new inventory,
however, is not expected to help the city in its efforts to generate additional
convention business, as these facilities feature limited meeting space.
As such, officials are being forced to reconsider the future of the Prime
Osborn Convention Center and its implications on the local economy. Two
alternatives being analyzed are the development of a new 150,000 square
feet facility with an attached hotel or the expansion of the existing infrastructure.
--
The Ernst & Young 2002 Florida Lodging Forecast contains an analysis
of data compiled from many sources, with credits identified. The contents
of this report is for reference only, not to be used as business advertisement
or to set standards on
policies or actions.
For additional information on the topics contained in the 2002 Florida
Lodging Forecast, or for information about services provided by the Ernst
& Young Real Estate Advisory Services Group, please contact any of
the following individuals:
© 2002 Ernst & Young
All Rights Reserved.
Ernst & Young is a registered trademark. |