Hotel Online  Special Report

advertisement


   Jakarta Shangri-La Hotel Workers Continue 
Struggle Against Unfair Dismissal
11 JULY 2001 - The Regional Secretariat of the International Union of Food, Agricultural, Hotel, Restaurant, Catering and Allied Workers Associations (IUF) in Asia and the Pacific has been informed of recent statements by Halilintar Nurdin, the former president of the Shangri-La Independent Workers' Union (SPMS), and the Management of the Jakarta Shangri-La Hotel.  These statements have claimed that the IUF is an illegitimate party to the dispute, that the Shangri-La dispute is effectively over and that negotiation for compensation for the remaining dismissed workers continues.  Such statements are incorrect and vigorously contested by the IUF.
 
The IUF, as an international labour federation of unions, which the SPMS is affiliated to through its membership to the Indonesian Independent Hotel Workers Federation (FSPM), was responsible and duty bound to come to the aid of the SPMS when it was brutally attacked.  This aid will remain constant for so long as the attack continues. 
 
Workers at Jakarta's 5-star Shangri-La Hotel have been seeking negotiations with hotel management since October to resolve issues of fundamental concern to the workforce, including the absence of an employee pension plan and a fair distribution of the service charge.
The IUF is not a �third party� as alleged, but very much a part of the SPMS and vice versa.  Moreover, any support the IUF renders for the SPMS, either financial or otherwise, is an expression of solidarity by one section of the organisation to another.  It is mischievous and misleading to suggest that the IUF has no right to assist or no responsibility to the SPMS, whose members and families are in need of food. 

As a result of Management's persistent actions to maintain the protracted lock-out of workers and deny them their capacity to earn a living, the IUF took the view that it could not stand by while the members and families of its affiliate were starved into submission, simply because the Shangri-La workers sought to be represented by a union of their choice, a right guaranteed under Indonesian law.

The IUF questions the assertion that the Shangri-La Management is still negotiating with the remaining locked-out workers.  There is no genuine negotiation taking place. The union is totally ignored by the Shangri-La Management, whose actions on industrial relations issues are led by the Lyman group, a major shareholder of the hotel. 

Instead, workers are being approached, one by one or in small groups, to accept offers of compensation to give up the struggle for their jobs and their rights. By their actions, Management has proved that their continuing objective is union busting. The real issues that gave rise to the dispute in the first place are totally suppressed, with Management still evading genuine good faith negotiation with the union.

The IUF affirms that in the present situation where a substantial number of Shangri-La workers continue their struggle for justice and against unfair dismissal, it remains in support of the SPMS. Although the SPMS union has had a change of leadership recently, its current membership is committed to securing justice.

The IUF, currently composed of 334 unions in 120 countries, was founded in 1920 to protect members and workers who are oppressed.  IUF affiliates have observed Management�s relentless oppression of Shangri-La workers in disgust and indignation and have expressed this to Indonesian missions throughout the world (in Bangkok, Stockholm, the Hague, Washington DC, Toronto, Brussels, Los Angeles and Geneva), via protests outside other Shangri-La hotels, and through a fund-raising campaign to provide the Shangri-La workers with money to feed themselves and their families.

We understand the pressure that Halilintar Nurdin, the former union president must be under. However, we feel saddened by the statements he made, considering that it was his dismissal in December last year that caused Shangri-La workers to protest and rally spontaneously to his defense. They trusted him and gave him unstinting support even to the extent of being dismissed themselves.

Therefore, the IUF reiterates the following:

  • The Shangri-La dispute had its origins late last year in Management intransigence to negotiate in good faith over the proper distribution of the service charge and the implementation of a pension plan;
  • It is unfortunate that Shangri-La Jakarta Management chose to pursue a strategy of union-busting and lock-out rather than negotiate amicably with the union; 
  • The IUF continues to pursue the Shangri-La case at the International Labour Organisation (ILO), the United Nations' body that sets and upholds international standards of labour rights; 
  • The decisions of the P4P and P4D (the labour-dispute settlement bodies), which acceded to Management's requests for the dismissal of the Shangri-La workers, will be appealed by the SPMS at the Administrative Court.
The IUF, from the moment the lock-out began in December last year, has always advocated, in writing and in public fora, for Management and the owners of the Jakarta Shangri-La hotel to negotiate in good faith with SPMS.  Instead of trying to negotiate individual deals with each union member, we again urge the Shangri-La Management to sit down and negotiate an amicable settlement with the Shangri-La Independent Workers' Union.

The International Union of Food, Agricultural, Hotel, Restaurant, Catering, Tobacco and Allied Workers' Associations (IUF) is an international trade union federation composed of 334 trade unions in 120 countries with an affiliated membership of 2.5 million members. It is headquartered in Geneva, Switzerland.  The IUF Asia & Pacific Regional Organisation is based in Sydney, Australia.

Contact:

Bandung: Hemasari Dharmabumi
IUF Indonesia
tel +62 22 203 5715
Sydney: Jasper Goss
Information Officer
IUF Asia & Pacific
tel +61 2 9264 6409

###



 


To search Hotel Online data base of News and Trends Go to Hotel.Online Search

Home |Welcome! | Hospitality News | Classifieds | Catalogs & Pricing | Viewpoint Forum | Ideas/Trends
Please contact Hotel.Online with your comments and suggestions.