Boulder, Colorado�December 22, 1998 � While Wall Street
saved the lodging industry after the market collapse of the early 1990s,
it did not create a �perfect market,� according to Dan King, vice president
of HVS International in Boulder, Colo. In fact, rather than making the
industry less susceptible to the excesses and market plunges characterized
by the 1980s to early 1990s, the public markets have made the peaks higher,
the valleys lower and the cycles shorter.
�Now that the era of rapid REIT expansion and �easy deals� is over,
it remains to be seen if Wall Street will make the sale of a hotel simpler,
or subject to less market imperfection,� says King. �At the moment, it
appears that the market has given us the illusion of efficiency, and rather
than providing discipline, the market may have made the industry more susceptible
to fluctuating volatility, quarterly earning reports and the �madness of
the crowds.��
King compares the hotel industry over the past 15 years and the problems
of the early 1990s resulting from overbuilding, the 1990 recession and
the coup de grace of the Gulf War forcing national occupancy levels to
drop to 61 percent. Delinquent loans, loans in foreclosure and owners selling
properties at liquidation prices resulted in values dropping precipitously
low and a total loss of value over a two-year period of 35 percent, or
17.5 percent per year, says King. �The loss of value during the early 1990s
was a debacle during which the industry painfully demonstrated its undisciplined
and inefficient nature.�
Tierra Centre
4730 Walnut Street
Suite 201
Boulder, Colorado 80301
(303) 443-3933
(303) 443-4186 FAX
|
Occupancy levels started to recover as early as 1992, and
by 1994 many markets had reached robust occupancy levels and hotel managers
responded by increasing room rates. Beginning in 1992, the public markets
through C-Corps, Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) and commercial mortgage-backed
securities (CMBSs) became the primary source of both equity and debt for
the lodging industry.
The REITs and C-Corps had virtually insatiable appetites for existing
lodging assets, said King, but in 1998 the lodging industry�s financial
fortunes entered into a transitional period. Stock prices of the |
REITs dropped as it became apparent the opportunities for rapid expansion
had been depleted, and a change in the tax codes that would specifically
impact two of the highest flying lodging REITs -- Starwood Lodging Trust
and Patriot American Hospitality. Additionally, the purportedly low leveraged
REITs had indeed found a way to leverage their future through complex forward
equity schemes. |