News for the Hospitality Executive
By Jim Butler of the Global Hospitality Group®
Author of www.HotelLawBlog.com
May 7, 2012
EB-5 LAWYER ALERT: California has adopted a new TEA policy as of April 30, 2012. It will severely affect California's ability to compete for EB-5 financing.
My partners, Catherine Holmes and Victor Shum, have alerted us to an important new development that will affect new development projects in California.
The State of California has decided that it will not certify any new "targeted employment areas" or TEAs under the EB-5 immigrant investor visa program.
If you develop hotels and other real estate, you are well aware of the financing opportunities provided by the EB-5 immigrant investor visa program -- and you are also know the importance of locating your project in a TEA. (If you are new to the intricacies of EB-5 financing, check out our articles on the topic on the Hotel Law Blog.)
The purpose of the EB-5 financing program is to create new jobs for Americans using investment from foreign investors who want to get a green card. Hotel developers, who have been unable to develop projects for years because of lack of traditional financing, are successfully using for new projects.
Our hotel lawyers have advised clients on more than 40 EB-5 projects, and we know this program is working. There are cities and counties throughout the U.S. -- including California -- that want these projects and the jobs that come with them.
For the full story, read the article below. We hope you will be moved to contact your city and state representatives and let them know that restricting TEA designations will restrict economic growth! This action is contrary to what virtually every other state in the Union is doing. Some of the biggest states have gone to great lengths to facilitate TEA designation both with speedy processing (it normally takes only 24-48 hours to get designation) and by flexibility in finding ways to meet the requirements. Why would California turn away this "free capital" from foreign investors to create jobs for Americans? Something is wrong.
EB-5 ALERT: California's new TEA approachCalifornia has adopted new policies that will deny EB-5 financing to many projects. On April 30, 2012, the California Department of Business, Transportation and Housing Agency released a bombshell that will have substantial negative effects on California businesses seeking to raise financing through the EB-5 immigrant investor visa program. For all practical purposes, the State of California's action will deny many California cities the ability to attract EB-5 investments because the State has decided that it will no longer issue "Targeted Employment Area" or "TEA" designations to any new areas other than the ones it designated in a letter dated April 30, 2012.
will limit ability to compete for EB-5 immigrant investor financing
Catherine DeBono Holmes and Victor Shum | Hotel Lawyers
This means that cities like San Francisco, San Diego, San Jose, Anaheim, and dozens of other cities, will be denied the ability for all practical purposes to raise EB-5 financing for new projects. Californians have a strong interest in the EB-5 program, as indicated by the fact that 59 of all approved U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) regional centers are located in California - which is over 25% of all regional centers. We believe this new policy needs to be changed immediately because California stands to lose out to other States in billions of dollars of foreign investment and thousands of new jobs. We are reaching out to State officials to reconsider this short sighted policy and will update you on any developments.
EB-5 financing is raising billions of dollars in financing for United States businesses and creates thousands of jobs. As our readers know, the EB-5 investor visa program allows non-U.S. persons to obtain United States permanent residency (green card) if they invest $1,000,000 in a new commercial enterprise that creates at least 10 new, permanent, full-time jobs per investor. If the new commercial enterprise is located within a TEA, the required investment is reduced to the $500,000 level (while still creating 10 full-time jobs).
This program has already raised billions of dollars in financing for job-creating U.S. businesses since 1992, and is poised this year to top all records for the amount of financing raised for U.S. businesses. As of March 20, 2012, there had already been 2,405 EB-5 visas issued for the first quarter of 2012, with Chinese nationals continuing to dominate the list (accounting for nearly 70% of EB-5 visas issued in 2011 and 2012 to date). The entire EB-5 program has a cap of 10,000 EB-5 visas per year. That could potentially represent several billion dollars of financing for new U.S. businesses every year.
Several factors are causing an increase in demand for EB-5 visas. The reasons for the big increase in demand for EB-5 visas include the big increase in developers seeking alternative financing (due to the lack of traditional financing), more Chinese investors seeking the benefits U.S. education and residency for themselves and their children, and similar investor visa programs in other countries, notably Canada, have a waiting list that stretches four years or more. In contrast, EB-5 investors can obtain a U.S. visa in six to eight months for qualified investment projects. The value that this program brings to cities around the U.S. cannot be underestimated, particularly as every city is working hard to recover from the economic crisis that began in 2008. This program brings thousands of jobs and millions of dollars to every community where new businesses are funded through the EB-5 program.
The market for EB-5 investments is competitive and almost all EB-5 investments are sold at the $500,000 level. As you might expect, there is huge demand for EB-5 financing in the U.S., particularly among hotel and other real estate developers who have been unable to develop projects for years because of lack of traditional financing. As a result, there is strong competition among projects for EB-5 financing, and potential non-U.S. investors are looking for the best projects in which to invest.
One of the most important criteria they look for is how much do they have to invest in order to qualify for the EB-5 visa? All things being equal, an investor will invest in a project that requires only a $500,000 investment rather than a $1,000,000 investment. Consequently, virtually all EB-5 investors have gravitated to $500,000 threshold projects. The corollary to this is that it is virtually impossible for any project to raise EB-5 financing if it does not qualify for the $500,000 investment level. To a project developer, that means you are likely not going to be able to attract EB-5 financing if your project is not in a TEA, because you won't be able to attract enough investors.
What is a TEA? The EB-5 regulations define a TEA as a rural area or an area which has experienced unemployment of at least 150% of the national average. For 2011, the national average unemployment rate was 8.9%, so any area with more than 13.4% unemployment will qualify. EB-5 regulations provide for two methods to evidence a TEA. One method is for an applicant to submit evidence to the USCIS for a determination that a metropolitan statistical area or county meets the required unemployed level to be designated as a TEA. The problem with this method is that a developer or investor won't know if an area qualifies for TEA status until after the I-526 petition or exemplar filing has been made (A more comprehensive discussion of this is below). The second and preferred method is to have a state certify the TEA status of a project location in advance. This allows the developer to confidently structure the new commercial enterprise in a manner that will be marketable to foreign investors.
The State of California has stated in its new policy that since an applicant can file with the USCIS for TEA designation, "state designation is not essential". We respectfully disagree. Given the many uncertainties with the EB-5 program, state certification of TEA status on a project by project basis (and not with a blanket form) is essential to make EB-5 projects within California marketable and competitive with projects in other states.
How do the states decide to designate TEAs? State and local agencies that have been empowered to certify TEAs are interpreting the EB-5 regulations differently with respect to the definition of "geographic or political subdivision". When reviewing census tract unemployment data, almost every state will look at data from multiple adjoining census tracts to determine what constitutes a geographic or political subdivision for purposes of establishing a TEA. Some states, including California, have taken different approaches to approving TEAs, and sometimes their approach results in a more restricted interpretation of what constitutes a geographic or political subdivision for purposes of TEA designation.
Not surprisingly, states and local agencies that use a more expansive method of determining the appropriate geographic area for a TEA are able to attract more EB-5 projects, because projects in TEAs can be sold at the $500,000 investment level, and almost all EB-5 investments are made at that level. The USCIS recently stated at the January 23, 2012, EB-5 Stakeholder Meeting that the USCIS "defers to the state's TEA designation in terms of the state's definition of the geographic boundaries of the TEA based upon high unemployment" so long as it is in compliance with statutory requirements. In other words, the USCIS will accept the methodology for determining geographic boundaries of a TEA adopted by each state.
California has decided not to work with business owners to designate TEAs. The California Business, Transportation and Housing Agency has now decided, according to the new procedures released on April 30, 2012, that it will not look at any local data for any project to make a determination of whether it is in a TEA. Instead, according to the website of the Governor's Office of Business and Economic Development,
[The] certification of TEAs is a uniform letter intended to be used by all EB-5 visa applicants....There will be no customized certification letters issued with the name of the investor, the description and the location of the new enterprise.... This certification of TEAs is an exhaustive list of the areas designated as TEAs by the State of California. There will be no other areas or subareas designated as TEAs.
You can find this new uniform letter, along with the procedures quoted above, at: http://business.ca.gov/Programs/EB5Program.aspx.
Some cities in California, including Los Angeles, Fresno, Sacramento, Long Beach and Oakland, are on the TEA designated list, so there is a small piece of good news for developers with projects in those cities.
Every city NOT listed in the uniform letter will lose EB-5 financing. If a city is not on the approved list, that city will not qualify for TEA designation from the State of California -- no matter if a project is in an economically depressed area of that city or not.
Thus, four of the largest cities in California -- San Francisco, San Diego, San Jose and Anaheim -- along with dozens of other California cities, will not qualify for a TEA from the State of California for any project in their city.
As a result, we can virtually guarantee that NONE of the cities that are left out of California's new uniform letter will be able to raise EB-5 financing in any meaningful amounts for projects located in those cities. The latest action by the State of California will deprive dozens of California cities and unemployed people of capital and new jobs under a program that does not cost the state of California or its taxpayers any money.
Is there any way to get a TEA other than from the State of California? It is possible for a project developer to apply for a TEA designation directly to the USCIS. However, as previously noted, that application is typically made at the time that either a regional center application is filed that includes a project in that area, as part of an I-526 exemplar application, or as part of the I-526 petition, which requires that all project documents be filed along with the application.
Most developers will not want to spend thousands of dollars on project documents until they know that their project will qualify as a TEA, because if the project area does not qualify for a TEA, the project will likely not be able to raise EB-5 financing at the $500,000 level. In addition, although the EB-5 regulations do allow the USCIS to make its own determination of whether an area qualifies as a TEA, we do not know if the USCIS will be willing to undertake the extra work involved in this analysis for every project that is not on the pre-approved TEA list for the State of California.
What happens if you already have a TEA letter from the State of California? According to the website of the Governor's Office of Business and Economic Development, "Investors who received special area designations in previous years may request a renewed certificate if it is for the same investment project, it covers the same subarea, and the then current unemployment data provides a high unemployment rate. Such requests will be handled on a case-by-case basis and renewed certificates might be issued at the discretion of the state." This means that if a project developer received a TEA designation before May 1, 2012, the developer may be able have that designation renewed, as long as the current unemployment data for the designated area still qualifies with unemployment above 13.4%.
What we are doing and you can do too. We are working to help those cities and developers who are negatively impacted by this new policy to work with the State Business, Transportation and Housing Agency to reverse this new policy so that everyone can compete for EB-5 financing.
If you have a project in a city that is not on the designated TEA list, call your city and state representatives and let them know that you need EB-5 financing and you can't get it without a TEA designation. Show them why your project area should be designated as a TEA, and tell them how many jobs your project will create.
We believe that California's new policy can be changed if the State Business, Transportation and Housing Agency understands the negative effect that their new policy will have on the many projects that are now seeking EB-5 financing throughout California.
Why everyone should support the EB-5 program. It is vitally important to every city in the United States to create new jobs and bring in new businesses, and EB-5 financing promotes those goals at no cost to the government or the taxpayers. This is one program where everyone wins -- cities, developers, workers and investors -- at no cost to the government.
We have talked to and worked with developers and EB-5 regional center operators all over the United States, and we have seen many successful new businesses funded with EB-5 financing. We know from our own experience that this is a program that benefits everyone and deserves strong support. In fact, the EB-5 financing program may be one of the few government programs that is supported by both major political parties. Our goal is to help more businesses to use this program to bring new jobs to every city throughout California and the United States.
For more information about EB-5 financing
EB-5 ALERT: California's new TEA approach will discourage EB-5 capital
EB-5 Lawyer with the latest wrinkle in EB-5 financing for hotels -- the Tenant Occupancy Issue
Financing new hotel development today: Finding the right "regional center" and negotiating terms for your EB-5 financing
Chinese investment in U.S. hotels: what the real estate professionals want to know
Hotel Development Lawyers: 10 things you can do to win the "race" for EB-5 capital for your hotel development project
Hotel Investment: Why Asian investors are targeting U.S. hotels for purchase and investment, and what could it mean for you?
Hotel Developers: Why a "regional center" may be the key to financing your next hotel development or expansion. And what you need to know . . .
How to use the EB-5 Immigrant Investor Visa Program for financing
Catherine Holmes is a transaction and finance partner with JMBM's Global Hospitality Group® and Chinese Investment Group™ and specializes in resort and hotel purchase and sale transactions, resort and urban mixed-use financing and development, hotel management and franchise agreements, and hospitality asset workouts. With her background in securities transactions, she also assists hotel developers with public and private offerings of securities. For more information, please contact Catherine Holmes at +1 310.201.3553 or [email protected].
Victor Shum is a corporate and securities partner in JMBM's Global Hospitality Group® and Chinese Investment Group™. He has advised clients on EB-5 matters since 1999 and assists hotel developers on EB-5 financing as well as public and private securities, mergers and acquisitions, cross-border issues, and other strategic business transactions, including real estate transactions and intellectual property and technology licensing matters. For more information, please contact Victor Shum at +1 415.984.9611 or [email protected].
Our Perspective. We represent hotel lenders, owners and investors. We have helped our clients find business and legal solutions for more than $60 billion of hotel transactions, involving more than 1,300 properties all over the world. For more information, please contact Jim Butler at [email protected] or +1 (310) 201-3526.
Jim Butler is a founding partner of JMBM, and Chairman of its Global Hospitality Group® and Chinese Investment Group™. Jim is one of the top hospitality attorneys in the world. GOOGLE "hotel lawyer" and you will see why.
Jim and his team are more than "just" great hotel lawyers. They are also hospitality consultants and business advisors. They are deal makers. They can help find the right operator or capital provider. They know who to call and how to reach them.
JMBM’s Global Hospitality Group®
The hotel lawyers in the Global Hospitality Group® of Jeffer Mangels Butler & Mitchell (JMBM) comprise the premier hospitality practice in a full-service law firm and are the authors of the Hotel Law Blog. We represent hotel owners, developers, investors and lenders and have helped our clients find business and legal solutions for more than $60 billion of hotel transactions, involving more than 1,300 properties worldwide. For more information about the Global Hospitality Group®, go to www.HotelLawBlog.com. For more information about full range of legal services provided by JMBM, go to www.JMBM.com.
is One of 20 Hottest Law Firms in the U.S. Per the National Law
Journal's Latest List / April 2012
Labor Lawyer: California Supreme Court Finally Gives Employers Some
Good News in Brinker Restaurant Corporation v. Superior Court / Jim
Butler & Travis Gemoets / April 2012
to Negotiate a Hotel Management Agreement. 10 Tips for a Smoother
Process / Jim Butler / March 2012
Defense Lawyer: What does the ADA pool lift compliance extension mean
to you? / Jim Butler / March 2012
Turnabout: Pool lift compliance deadline extended to May 15 / Jim
Butler / March 2012
Things to Remember when Buying Hotel Notes / Jim Butler / March 2012
Defense and Compliance Lawyer: More clarification or confusion on March
15 ADA standards? / Jim Butler / March 2012
ALERT - A Call to Action Before the March 15, 2012 ADA Deadline /
Jim Butler / February 2012
Interviews JMBM's ADA Defense and Compliance Lawyers: Hotels Handle
Pool Lift Regulations / Jim Butler / February 2012
Tips for Hotels; How to spot terrorists and what to do. / Jim
Butler / February 2012
Defense and Compliance Lawyer Advisory: DOJ Clarifies March 15, 2012
Mandatory Pool Lift Requirement! (Uh-oh!) / Jim Butler & Martin
Orlick / February 2012
Can You Pass This 3-Question ADA Pop Quiz? / Jim Butler / January
Lawyer in Los Angeles: ALIS - What's the commotion all about? Closing
the conference hotel to outsiders. / Jim Butler / January 2012
Management Contract Disputes: Importance of 'Fiduciary' Duties in
Owner-Operator Lawsuits / Jim Butler / January 2012
and Disputes Between Hotel Owners and Operators are on the Rise? Why?
/ Jim Butler / January 2012
Defense Lawyer: New ADA Regulations Kick in Soon. Say goodbye to
'grandfathering' under the ADA / Jim Butler / November 2011
Lawyer in Washington D.C. - Why the Lodging Industry Will Continue to
Do Well Despite Bumpy Markets and More / Jim Butler / November 2011
Investment in U.S. Hotels: What the Real Estate Professionals Want to
Know / Jim Butler / October 2011
Lawyer in Dallas Listening to the Special Servicers / Jim Butler /
Lawyer with Optimism for the Hotel Industry from the Dallas Lenders
Conference, Fishing for Solutions 2011 / Jim Butler / October 2011
Service Animal Policies of Your Hotel or Other 'Place of Lodging' /
Jim Butler, Martin Orlick and David Sudeck / October 2011
Industry Alert: Some things to feel (very) good about! / Jim Butler
/ September 2011
Lawyers in Phoenix: It's not just me. The market has changed in just
the last 60 days! / Jim Butler / September 2011
Labor and Employment Lawyer Update: Controversial Union Rights Notice
Subject to Legal Challenge - Employers Should Not Rush To Post It /
Jim Butler & Scott Brink / September 2011
Franchise Lawyer: Hotel Franchise Agreements and the 5 Biggest Mistakes
a Hotel Owner Can Make / Jim Butler & Robert Braun / September
Labor and Employment Lawyer Alert: The NLRB is making it harder to stay
union free / Jim Butler & Scott Brink / September 2011
from Hotel Franchise and Management Lawyers: Beware the Trap of
Changing Brand Standards / Jim Butler & Robert Braun /
and Employment Alert: New Law Requires Employers to Post Employee
Rights Notice by November 14, 2011; NLRB Publishes Final Rule for
Notification of Employee Rights / Scott Brink , JMBM / September
Lending Lawyer: What every hotel lender needs to know about hotel due
diligence / Jim Butler & Guy Maisnik / September 2011
Lending Lawyer: What every hotel lender needs to know about Cash
Controls / Jim Butler & Guy Maisnik / August 2011
Lawyers on Terminating Hotel Operators: M Edition Lawsuit Against
Marriott Has a New Twist Marriott is Replaced Overnight / Jim
Butler / August 2011
Lawyers on Terminating Hotel Operators: Turnberry Resort Drops Fairmont
Flag / Jim Butler / August 2011
Lending Lawyer: What every hotel lender needs to know about SNDA's
/ Jim Butler & Guy Maisnik / August 2011
Lending Lawyer: What every hotel lender needs to know about HMAs and
hotel franchise agreements / Jim Butler & Guy Maisnik / August
Lawyer on the Importance of Brands - Intellectual Property Rights and
What They Mean: Family Suites Resorts v. Viacom International d/b/a MTV
Networks - a Suit Over Branding / Jim Butler / August 2011
Lawyer on the Fiduciary, Contractual and Agency Duties of Hotel Brokers
- Host Hotels & Resorts LP v. Molinaro Koger Litigation / Jim
Butler / August 2011
Waikiki's Edition Lawsuit Against Marriott International and Ian
Schrager - an Owner's HMA Dispute with Marriott and What it All Means
/ Jim Butler / August 2011
Investment: Why Asian investors are targeting U.S. hotels for purchase
and investment, and what could it mean for you? / Jim Butler /
Developers: Why a "regional center" may be the key to financing your
next hotel development or expansion. And what you need to know... /
Jim Butler / July 2011
to use the EB-5 Immigrant Investor Visa Program for financing / Jim
Butler / July 2011
Announces Formation of the Chinese Investment Group™ - Hotels, Real
Estate, EB-5 Immigrant Investor Visas / July 2011
Lawyer: How do you know when you should set up a captive insurance
company for your hotel? Take our "litmus test". / Jim Butler &
Gordon Schaller / July 2011
Lawyer: What you need to know about the "ancillary benefits" of setting
up a captive insurance company / Jim Butler & Gordon Schaller /
Lawyer: Are you thinking about setting up a captive insurance company?
Maybe you should be. . . / Jim Butler & Gordon Schaller / June
Lawyer in New York with pre-NYU industry forecast: Sunny with
occasional clouds and NO storms on the horizon / Jim Butler / June
Lawyer with the Executive Roundtable Results; Debt is returning, equity
is out looking, and we've passed the bottom of the trough. Why now is
the time to purchase a hotel. / Jim Butler / June 2011
Defense Lawyer: How to Quickly Lose Business. (No ADA-Compliant
Reservation System) / Jim Butler & David Sudeck / May 2011
Lawyer with Fresh Perspectives on the Hotel Industry from Smith Travel
/ Jim Butler / May 2011
Lawyers with PKF and Mark Woodworth's Lodging Overview / Jim Butler
/ May 2011
Lawyers' Updates on Capital and Debt Markets for Hotels, Transaction
Sales Data and Financings / Jim Butler / May 2011
Lawyer with Updates on Hotel Cap Rates, Values and Transactions /
Jim Butler / May 2011
Lawyer with nuggets from JMBM's Meet the Money® 2011 / Jim
Butler / May 2011
Lawyer: The hotel transaction market is heating up! / Jim Butler /
Lawyer with good news! A new federal court decision upholds condo hotel
structure. No "securities" involved as structured. Disgruntled condo
hotel unit purchaser lawsuit dismissed. / Jim Butler / April 2011
the Money®: Hotel Financing Renaissance is Underway! / Jim
Butler / April 2011
Global Hospitality Group® announces publication of The HMA
Handbook, a FREE practical guide for negotiating Hotel Management
Agreements for Hotel Owners, Developers, Investors and Lenders /
a Hotel? Don't Buy an ADA Lawsuit or DOJ Investigation / Jim Butler
/ March 2011
Lawyer on Hotel Management Agreements: Exculpation Clauses for
Protecting the Owner's Assets / Jim Butler / February 2011
Defense Lawyer: How to handle an ADA lawsuit....and How not to do it
/ Jim Butler / February 2011
Lawyer: 5 Key Elements for Good Hotel Management Agreement Budget
Provisions / Jim Butler / February 2011
improving fundamentals make 2011 the year of "Great Expectations" for
the Hotel Industry / Jim Butler / February 2011
the Hotel Lawyer: 2011 is starting as the year of "Great Expectations"
for the hotel industry! / Jim Butler / January 2011
ADA Defense Lawyer: How a recent ADA case affects all hotels but
particularly conference centers and meeting hotels / Jim Butler /
Lawyer: So, You Think You Want to Buy a Hotel? For savvy investors, the
time could be right / Jim Butler / January 2011
Universal Hotel Sale Facilitated by JMBM's Global Hospitality Group®
/ Jim Butler / January 2011