News for the Hospitality Executive
Recap Caribbean Hotel & Tourism Investment Conference:
Robert Crandall, Former CEO of American
Airlines, Provides Frank and
Honest Assessment of the Issues Facing Caribbean Tourism
CSHAE Elects 2010-2011 Leadership
SAN JUAN, PUERTO RICO (May 13, 2010) – The Official Caribbean Hotel & Tourism Investment Conference (CHTIC 2010), hosted by the Caribbean Hotel & Tourism Association (CHTA) and Caribbean Tourism Organization (CTO), concluded last week in Puerto Rico on an upbeat note despite the lingering economic situation. The highlight of the conference was a highly anticipated keynote address from Robert Crandall, former Chairman and CEO of AMR Corporation and American Airlines.
No stranger to the unique challenges and difficulties faced by the Caribbean, Crandall (pictured right) advocated for a new regional marketing campaign and the easing of on-island taxation of the hospitality and tourism sector.
“The term ‘important conference’ is not an empty phrase, for the Caribbean is uniquely dependent on tourism, which means that solid, well financed, carefully thought out planning to sustain and increase the region’s attractiveness is enormously significant,” opened Crandall during his keynote address.
“As everyone involved in travel and tourism knows, the industry is immensely
important to the world economy, generating and supporting – either directly
or indirectly – about one in 11 jobs worldwide. Here in the Caribbean,
it is vastly more important. On a number of islands, travel and tourism
accounts for more than 50% of all employment, and on some for more than
75%. Overall, about 20% of all Caribbean employment is travel and tourism
dependent – something on the order of 2.5 million jobs,” he noted.
“2010 is well along, and there isn’t much we can agree on here that will have much impact this year, but there is lots that can and should be done to move 2011 and later years in the right direction – and lots of reasons why you should act promptly.
“Overall, I am a lot more pessimistic about 2011 than most popular forecasters
seem to be and, while I’d like to be proven wrong, I think everyone should
have a solid plan for what to do if substantial economic growth [in 2011]
turns out to be an illusion,” he warned.
Having earned the conference delegates’ full attention with his frank and honest assessment of the issues facing the industry, Crandall went on to provide three explicit examples of things that are not being done very well:
“I often think, when I arrive on one or another Caribbean island, that the immigration folks would prefer that I had not come. There is a minimum amount of automation and a maximum amount of standing in the sun waiting for the completion of lengthy documents that are almost surely consigned immediately thereafter to file 13. It’s time for every Caribbean government to improve immigration processes, minimize time spent and forms completed, and provide a welcoming rather than a hostile interface.
“Second, every destination that hopes to attract tourism needs to come to grips with the reality that we live in a continuously connected world. Tourists will avoid, and in time reject altogether, anywhere that does not make continuous, high quality internet connectivity a reality. As you all know, there are many places in the Caribbean that now fall short of that standard.
“And finally, there is a minimum level of public services that tourists will accept. No one wants to pass by uncollected garbage – and those who do are unlikely to return. Again, there are many Caribbean destinations that now fall short of minimum public service levels.
“Additionally, every government should undertake a full scale public education campaign – in schools, job sites, community organizations and every other relevant venue – to be certain that every citizen understands that whether he or she works directly in travel and tourism or not, that every tourist represents a contribution to the economy and that tourist dollars will bring economic and social benefits to every level of society.
“The second priority, in my view, should be to overcome resistance to regional marketing. As long ago as 1992, at a meeting held in Kingston, Jamaica, the region’s heads of government agreed to collaborate in a partnership with the private sector to organize and sustain – the key word is sustain – a regional marketing fund. Unhappily, despite substantial private sector contributions which led to a successful regional advertising program in 1992-93, and a second effort in 2002 which was also judged successful, the region’s governments have never reached agreement on either the wisdom of regional advertising and promotion or a mechanism for creating a sustaining fund to support regional branding.
“The 2004 World Travel & Tourism Council study had this to say about
the regional branding proposal: ‘there is insufficient consensus that regional
marketing for Caribbean tourism is necessary, appropriate or feasible at
this point in time, [but] there is still significant reluctance by a number
of the more independent destinations to undertake a regional marketing
effort,’” quoted Crandall.
“Whether you choose to create and promote a regional brand is up to you and the many governments in the region – like all consultants and friends of the court, I am here today but will be gone tomorrow. But I recommend it to you – and hope you will embrace the idea,” remarked Crandall in a plea to Caribbean governments.
“Finally, I think it is time you stopped taxing your own exports. Travel and tourism, although sometimes not recognized as such, is an export product – as with other exports, you derive revenues from abroad in exchange for a domestic product or service. In most cases, exports are encouraged, not taxed – but here in the Caribbean – and in other travel venues around the world – governments tax the tourism product rather heavily, thereby reducing the quantity consumers are willing to buy. That just doesn’t make much sense to me.
“I recognize, of course, that doing away with taxation overnight is simply not practical, since all governments need revenues with which to fulfill their service responsibilities. However, modifying taxation methodologies to recognize the importance of industry growth, and looking elsewhere for substitute revenues, should certainly be a high priority,” he explained.
“It is particularly egregious, it seems to me, to tax the most valuable customers the most heavily. I refer now, of course, to the continuing controversy regarding the taxation of cruise customers relative to the taxation of land side customers. While cruise customers are certainly to be valued, their stay is short and their average spend relatively modest.
“Land side visitors, on the other hand, typically stay for several days and nights and spend very substantial amounts. While I can certainly understand why individual destinations are reluctant to impose taxes not matched by competitive or neighboring destinations, it does seem to me that a regional agreement to impose reasonable taxes on cruise customers is an attractive way to mitigate the tax burden now borne by those you would like to have back next year.”
Having received several ovations throughout his address, Crandall concluded his remarks with a summary:
“First, I see hard times ahead, and I urge you to think now about how to deal with them. Second, I think you have many great advantages which, if used properly, will enable you to prosper despite the economic troubles I anticipate. Third, I think you should band together and create an effective organization to educate everyone in the area about how important travel and tourism is and how each individual – and every department of every government – can contribute to its greater success. Fourth, I think you should consider – once again – the wisdom of banding together to shape and promote brand Caribbean.
“And finally, I think you should stop taxing your most valuable export – or at the very least, minimize that activity,” urged Crandall, noting that his advice is “not much different than what every business and every government, everywhere in the world, ought to do if it wants to compete more successfully.”
Crandall was applauded continuously throughout his remarks as conference participants were extremely grateful for the wisdom he generously imparted on delegates attending the Official Caribbean Hotel & Tourism Investment Conference (CHTIC 2010), hosted May 4-6 by CHTA and CTO in conjunction with the Puerto Rico Tourism Company (PRTC), Puerto Rico Hotel & Tourism Association (PRHTA) and Puerto Rico Convention Bureau (PRCB).
Caribbean Hotel & Tourism Association
|Also See:||Caribbean Society of Hotel Association Executives Agree on Six Point Plan for National Associations; Susan Springer, Executive Director of the Barbados Hotel & Tourism Association Re-elected President / May 2008|
|Caribbean Hotel Association Recognizes Individuals that Raise the Bar for Caribbean Hospitality; Eustace Guishard, GM of Cap Juluca Resort in Anguilla Named “Caribbean Hotelier of the Year” / July 2005|