Hotel Online
News for the Hospitality Executive

Millennium & Copthorne Hotels New Zealand Alleging Deceit, Intimidation
and the Breaking of Company Seals by a Partner in a Business Venture
that has Gone Sour in China

Millennium & Copthorne Hotels plc (“M&C”) Statement concerning Chinese Joint Venture

April 12, 2010

The following announcement was released earlier today by M&C’s subsidiary, Millennium & Copthorne Hotels New Zealand Limited (“MCHNZ”), which is listed on the New Zealand Stock Exchange. M&C has a 70.2% interest in MCHNZ. M&C’s effective interest in First Sponsor Capital Limited (“FSCL”) is 39.8%.

Based on the unaudited management accounts of the FSCL Group as at 28 February 2010, FSCL’s carrying value of the net assets of and a loan to the Hainan Hotel Owning Company and the Dongguan Owning Company (both of which are defined in the MCHNZ announcement) is US$47.8 million. M & C’s effective interest is US$ 19.0 million or £12.7 million.

M&C’s management is taking all possible action to protect the group’s interests in those assets.

Millennium & Copthorne Hotels New Zealand Limited (NZX:MCK) issues the following statement with regard to its interest in its Chinese Joint Venture:

MCK wishes to report that its Chinese joint venture, held through its 34% interest in First Sponsor Capital Limited (“FSCL”) (which in turn owns a 75% interest in Idea Valley Investment Holdings Ltd (“IVIHL”)), has encountered certain difficulties arising from the actions initiated by one of FSCL’s Chinese joint venture partners (a company controlled by Mr Cheung Ping Kwong (“Cheung”) which owns a 20% interest in IVIHL).

IVIHL in turn owns 100% interest in Idea Valley Group Limited (“IVGL”) which is involved with property related businesses in Guangdong and Hainan, China. Cheung was the founder of IVGL.

Under a joint venture agreement dated 27 September 2007 (“JVA”), Cheung was granted management rights over IVGL and its subsidiaries (“IVGL Group”). Owing to Cheung’s failure to meet the conditions in the JVA, Cheung ceased to be entitled to exercise such management rights over IVGL Group. Principally for this reason and Cheung’s management conduct, the IVGL board resolved on 20 November 2009 that (a) Cheung cease to be the Chief Executive Officer (“CEO”) of IVGL; and (b) the company seals of IVGL Group and two of its related companies (collectively, the “i-vale Entities”) be placed under the control of IVGL’s Chief Financial Officer (“CFO”) (an appointee of FSCL).

Cheung refused to comply with the 20 November 2009 IVGL board resolutions, and accordingly, the IVGL directors and management (at a meeting on 26 November 2009) confirmed the appointment of IVGL’s new interim CEO who, together with his management team, would take over IVGL’s daily operations.

In March 2010, Cheung:-

  • through deceit seized unilateral control of the company seals of all the i-vale Entities;
  • terminated the employment of FSCL’s various appointees in IVGL (including the IVGL CFO) without appropriate authority; and
  • unlawfully took control of IVGL’s office and denied IVIHL its rights to access i-vale Entities’ books, accounts, records, bank statements and other information.
As soon as these were discovered, the boards of the relevant i-vale Entities (i) removed Cheung from his appointments as Chairman, director and legal representative (except in the case of three i-vale Entities for which further legal steps are necessary to effect the removal), and (ii) rendered void the seals which had been seized by and were under the control of Cheung.

In China, the affixing of the company seal, together with the legal representative’s signature, represents the full authority of the company. Accordingly, as an added precaution, the i-vale Entities issued press notices in a major newspaper in China, on 30 March 2010 to notify that Cheung had been removed from his various appointments and that the company seals under Cheung’s control were void. By 12 April 2010, the relevant Chinese authorities had registered the new seals for five i-vale Entities (including IVGL) and the change in IVGL’s legal representative to an appointee of FSCL was completed.

Notwithstanding these steps to protect IVIHL’s interests in the joint venture, on 8 and 9 April 2010, IVIHL learned that Cheung (without any authority from the board of IVGL or the relevant i-vale Entity) procured:-

  • the disposal of IVGL’s 100% interest in the i-vale Entity (“Hainan Hotel Owning Company”), which owns the West Coast Resort Hainan Hotel (“Hainan Hotel”), to a party which in August 2008 had commenced litigation in Hainan, China, courts in connection with the Hainan Hotel. IVIHL learned that Cheung had used unconventional business practices (including intimidation and forceful tactics) to seize the seals and other corporate documents of the Hainan Hotel Owning Company in favour of the purchaser, and that of another i-vale Entity which operates and manages the Hainan Hotel and does not form part of the disposal; and
  • the disposal of IVGL’s 80% interest in the i-vale Entity which owns a mixed use development project in Dongguan, China (“Dongguan Owning Company”), to Cheung’s close associate.
IVIHL has taken and is continuing to take all necessary measures to protect its interests in the i-vale Entities, including:-
  • completing the relevant filings with the PRC authorities to confirm the removal of Cheung from his various i-vale Entity appointments and the voiding of the seals which are under his control;
  • seeking legal advice on these disposals procured by Cheung (including an assessment of the validity of such transactions);
  • reporting Cheung’s unauthorised actions and his apparent scheme to cause loss and damage to the Chinese joint venture to various PRC governmental authorities and bodies with an urgent request for such PRC authorities’ assistance and cooperation to prevent loss and damage to IVIHL’s interests in the i-vale Entities;
  • preparing a report to be lodged with the PRC police authorities concerning the stolen company seals, as well as the disposals; and
  • replacing the new seals and filing the change in legal representative for the remaining i-vale Entities.
This process would typically require the existing seals and corporate documents of these i-vale Entities which however are in Cheung’s control.

IVIHL is dependent on the assistance and cooperation from the various PRC governmental authorities and bodies to prevent loss and damage to IVIHL’s interests in the i-vale Entities.

The remaining operations of the IVIHL Group, principally in Sichuan, China and which constituted approximately 38% of FSCL Group’s net assets remain under the control of FSCL.

Based on the unaudited management accounts of the FSCL Group as at 28 February 2010, FSCL’s carrying value of the net assets of and a loan to the Hainan Hotel Owning Company and the Dongguan Owning Company is US$47.8 million. MCK’s effective interest is approximately US$ 16.3 million or NZ$22.7 million (based on a US$1/ NZ$1.39 exchange rate as at 12 April 2010).

Issued by Millennium & Copthorne Hotels New Zealand Limited


Buchanan Communications 
Tel: +44 (0) 20 7466 5000
Charles Ryland/Nicola Cronk

Millennium & Copthorne Hotels plc 
Tel: +44 (0) 20 7872 2444
Beng-Lan Low, SVP Finance / 
Adrian Bushnell, Company Secretary

Also See: Millennium Hotels and Resorts Adds a Kingsgate Branded Property, the Former Best Western Portland Hotel of Thorndon, Located in Wellington, New Zealand / February 2007

To search Hotel Online data base of News and Trends Go to Hotel.OnlineSearch
Home | Welcome| Hospitality News | Classifieds| One-on-One |
Viewpoint Forum | Industry Resources | Press Releases
Please contact Hotel.Onlinewith your comments and suggestions.