The Smart Hotelier’s Guide to 2015 Digital Marketing Budget Planning
August 22, 2014 9:13am
By Max Starkov and Mariana Mechoso Safer
For the ninth year in a row, HeBS Digital announces the launch of "The Smart Hotelier's Guide to 2015 Digital Marketing Budget Planning," just in time for the 2015 budget planning season.
This article outlines how to structure your budget so that you can shift more bookings to the direct online channel, better utilize your marketing dollars by increasing campaign effectiveness, and generate the highest returns possible from your property website and digital marketing initiatives.
We recommend that hoteliers frame their digital marketing plan within two main categories:
This straightforward approach seamlessly covers all the digital marketing, technology and asset management line items that hospitality marketers need to maximize direct online revenues, address specific property business needs throughout the year, and meet all of your property's website design, consulting and technology needs.
The article also covers:
Continue reading the article below, or download the white paper: The Smart Hotelier’s Guide to 2015 Digital Marketing Budget Planning (PDF Format).
The 2015 Budgeting Season Is Already Here!
The season for digital marketing reflection is here. As an industry we reflect on the performance of this year's initiatives, forecast next year's performance, and look ahead to the big ideas and proven initiatives that will generate increased online revenue opportunities. Hoteliers, we've quickly found ourselves in the midst of budgeting season!
Similar to this year, 2015 is expected to be another year that sees growth in all 3 key metrics for the U.S. hotel industry. By the end of 2014, the industry is predicted to have seen increases in occupancy (1.4%), ADR (4.2%), and RevPAR (5.7%). In 2015, occupancy is expected to increase 0.6 percent to 63.5 percent, ADR by 4.3 percent to US$119.93 and RevPAR by 4.9 percent to US $76.13. Demand is expected to grow 2.2 percent, supply by 1.6 percent (STR and Tourism Economics).
Capturing increased demand, shifting share from the OTAs to the property website, and bringing in higher ROIs takes a smart digital marketing strategy. Hoteliers that underspend in digital marketing and underestimate the sheer volume of consumers researching and booking online will continue to lose market share to their competitors and the OTAs.
Important Factors Impacting our Industry
Before we dive into how to structure your 2015 budget, here are a few important factors that are making an impact on the overall direct online channel strategy for our clients.
Acceleration in Shift from Desktop to Mobile & Tablet
Over 42% of website visitors and nearly 16% of bookings came from tablet and mobile devices in the first half of 2014. Visitors to desktop sites declined 16% year over year while increasing by nearly 51% on mobile devices.
Hoteliers must meet the needs of the multi-device user by boosting their presence in the three screens (desktop, mobile and tablet). Year-over-year web analytics no longer paint the full picture because the majority of mobile bookings come from the voice channel.
We are living in a multi-device world and people are always connected, always 'online.' Hotel marketers must be able to not only deliver the optimal experience regardless of device, they also need to adjust how they measure results: online conversion data alone should not drive decisions on digital marketing spend and performance.
Multichannel Marketing Essential to Reach Customers at All Touch Points
There's a lot of research and multi-device behavior that goes into the travel booking process. According to Google, the average length in days before a purchase is 24, and average site visits before purchase is 21.6. Just one website visit or just one marketing initiative to reach your potential guests is not enough. Driving more engagement and more bookings requires using multiple channels (the website, paid search, SEO, email marketing, social media, retargeting, etc.) to promote one campaign.
Search Engines Still King of Direct Online Distribution
In spite of all the new revenue opportunities available to hoteliers today - such as new technology developments, retargeting capabilities, new marketing channels and more, search engines still rule direct distribution. They are responsible for over 50% of traffic to hotel websites.
Hoteliers often underestimate this when it comes to their SEM/paid search and SEO budgets. To ensure that your property is maximizing revenues from the search engines, it's important to continuously optimize SEM and SEO strategies. Keep reading for tips on how to properly allocate budget dollars to SEM and SEO next year.
Dynamic Rate Marketing (DRM) Creates New Revenue Opportunities at High ROI
Hotels, resorts, and casinos can now seamlessly integrate real-time availability and pricing in various marketing initiatives: From meta search to display advertising via the top travel ad networks, retargeting and Google Adwords to email marketing. This combination of online advertising and marketing campaigns with real-time hotel inventory availability and pricing provides hoteliers with a new direct response marketing channel while satisfying travelers' demands for instant and truthful hotel pricing information, as well as respond in real time to changing market conditions and comp set behavior.
In the beginning of the year, HeBS Digital predicted that 2014 would be the year of Dynamic Rate Marketing and later published a groundbreaking article "Dynamic Rate Marketing - Hotelier's Powerful New Weapon to Shift Share from the OTAs." This type of marketing is already producing returns of 2500% or 25 to 1 on top travel networks for clients, and this is just the beginning.
Action Plan for Preparing the 2015 Digital Marketing Budget
Underspending in digital marketing has been a problem in our industry for years. Hoteliers should be spending a minimum of 4% of their total room revenue on advertising/marketing efforts, of which 75% should be spent on digital marketing. How can we justify such a high percentage going to digital? In 2015, over 50% of hotel rooms will be booked online, including 45% transient and at least 5%-10% of group roomnights. Additionally, the vast majority of travel consumers, leisure and corporate alike, plus corporate group planners and SMERF group organizers, do their travel planning and research online.
Maximizing revenues from your property website and shifting share from the OTAs requires a dual focus: smart investments in your digital assets and the right mix of direct response digital marketing campaigns.
Your 2015 budget should be broken down in the following manner:
I. Direct Response Digital Marketing Campaigns: Line items that drive high revenues for hospitality companies such as SEM, SEO, Email Marketing, Meta search Marketing, Social Media, and Website Conversion Enhancements are all considered direct response marketing initiatives. When taking into account the actual budget allocated to each initiative, HeBS Digital recommends taking a Year-Round and Seasonal/Business-Needs focused approach.
1. Year-Round: Certain digital marketing initiatives are proven revenue generators and deserve a significant portion of the budget allocated to them year-round. This includes SEM, SEO, Email Marketing, Metasearch, Dynamic Rate Marketing on the top travel networks, and more.
2. Seasonal & Business-Need Focused: This portion of the budget takes into account a property's seasonality as well as specific business-needs such as how to target specific high value segments (i.e. meeting planners, family travelers, etc.) or fill rooms after a group cancellation. The Seasonal & Business Needs focused budget should remain dynamic and flexible as the year progresses. Many initiatives in the year-round budget may overlap here, however they will be organized into a multi-channel campaign that promotes one cohesive message throughout multiple channels.
II. Digital Assets, Website Revenue Optimization Consulting+ Strategy & Operations: These line items provide the necessary foundation for digital marketing success. This includes a responsive website that accommodates consumer behavior on the three screens (desktop, mobile, tablet), your Content Management System, website revenue optimization consulting and strategy, web analytics, and cloud hosting.
I. Direct Response Digital Marketing Campaigns and Initiatives
Initiatives in this section of the budget all have one major goal in mind: to drive online bookings and leads. Advancements in technology and smarter targeting capabilities this year are helping hoteliers to achieve higher ROIs through their own website. Additionally, advancements such as Dynamic Rate Marketing are turning predominantly branding initiatives into direct-response initiatives, driving initiatives such as banner advertising higher up the purchase funnel.
These initiatives should be included in the budget year-round and consistently generate high returns for all types of hospitality companies.
Every year, Google's algorithm changes more than 500 times. A property website is "never done with SEO" as illustrated by our recent article "SEO is a Journey, Not a Destination: How to Implement an Ongoing SEO Strategy and Maximize Website Revenue."
Hotel websites have to keep up with high new standards imposed by the search engines who demand fresh, unique, engaging and deep relevant content and must meet the standards of '"Editorial Quality" mandated by the Hummingbird update. SEO must also align with SEM/Paid Search campaigns for higher Quality Index of campaigns and stronger ROIs.
Did you know that sixty-two percent of the results on Google show different results on mobile devices compared to desktop and that 27 percent of websites are misconfigured for smartphone searches (BrightEdge). Optimizing for the three screens (desktop, mobile and tablet) is another important factor to consider.
SEO generates 30%-35% of website revenue across HeBS Digital's hotel client portfolio. Hoteliers must budget for ongoing SEO support, long after the website launches. Maximizing revenues from organic search results is a year-long effort.
SEO action items to put in the budget:
Partner with a hospitality-focused SEO firm who combines in-house professional copywriting with expert SEO services as demanded by the search engines. Please read "The Top 10 Questions Hoteliers Should Be Asking Their SEO Vendor."
Recommended share of the budget: 8%-10%
B. SEM / Paid Search
Paid search generates 20%-25% of website revenue across HeBS Digital's hotel client portfolio. Paid search is one of the highest drivers of direct online channel revenues, which is why we continuously dedicate such a large portion of the budget to it. Managing these campaigns, however, is becoming increasingly complex year after year and requires a greater time commitment to achieve high returns.
Here are some of the reasons why launching, managing and optimizing paid search campaigns requires a much higher level of expertise and time commitment today:
Partnering with an SEM/Paid Search firm with in-house SEM expertise who focuses on SEM in hospitality is a pre-requisite to the success of your paid search campaigns. Please read "The Top Ten Questions to Ask Your Paid Search Vendor."
Recommended share of the budget: 20%-25%
C. Meta Search Marketing
Meta search marketing is a "must have" initiative for any independent hotel, resort and casino and any small and mid-size hotel chain; it is as important as SEO, SEM and email marketing and should be part of every hotel's effort to shift share away from the OTAs and increase direct bookings.
Travel consumers go to metasearch sites/platforms such as TripAdvisor and Google HPA as part of their hotel stay research process and to validate their hotel choice. Reading a property's great reviews helps to close the loop on travel research and booking, bringing metasearch websites closer to the purchase stage in the conversion funnel.
As a marketing format, meta search marketing is quite complex due to the fact that it requires real-time room availability and pricing, in addition to daily campaign and bid management.
Contrary to some perceptions in the industry, meta search is not a distribution channel, nor is it a "set and forget" marketing initiative. It is a cost-per-click (CPC) advertising format, where the advertiser pays only when someone clicks on their listing and is taken deep into their booking engine. Meta search marketing is and should be used as an advertising model and not a distribution channel. Please read why "Treating Meta Search Marketing as a Distribution Channel Results in Loss of Direct Revenues for Hoteliers."
Since only the top three positions on TripAdvisor and the top two on Google HPA/Hotel Finder matter, just being enabled means nothing since without daily campaign and bid management the OTAs will push the property down or out of the pricing ad menu.
Recommended share of the budget: 10%-12%
D. Dynamic Rate Marketing - Top Travel Networks
Dynamic Rate Marketing (DRM) is a next-generation direct-response marketing category which allows real-time hotel inventory availability and pricing to be inserted in various marketing initiatives: from display advertising to retargeting, meta search and email marketing.
Dynamic rate banner advertising and retargeting has already proven to be a very successful direct-response advertising format on several specialized ad networks, generating significantly higher conversions and ROIs than banner advertising without dynamic rates.
Dynamic Rate Marketing dramatically increases campaign effectiveness, boosts conversion rates, and increases direct online bookings. By combining online advertising and marketing campaigns with real-time hotel inventory availability and pricing, hoteliers can satisfy travelers' demands for instant and truthful hotel pricing information, as well as respond in real-time to changing market conditions and comp set behavior. Even with such complex technology behind it, Dynamic Rate Marketing is surprisingly cost-effective, quick, and easy for hoteliers to implement today.
Please read more about why Dynamic Rate Marketing is Hotelier's Powerful New Weapon to Shift Share from the OTAs.
Recommended share of the budget: 10%- 12%
E. Online Media and Retargeting
Influenced by unprecedented advancements in technology, display advertising is growing at a staggering 21 percent and is expected to surpass paid search in 2015 (ZenithOptimedia 2014).
While complex on the backend, the newest technologies available in display advertising are surprisingly cost-effective, quick and easy for hoteliers to implement today. A great example of the endless opportunities for hotel marketers is The Google Display Network (GDN):
The Google Display Network is the largest global network, reaching over 87% of Internet users worldwide and 94% of all US Internet users per month. Its collection of over 2 million publishers includes hundreds of comScore's top 1,000 sites. Hoteliers should not only have a presence in this space, but they should be using the latest digital targeting innovations to bring qualified visitors and potential bookers to their site, such as:
Similar Audiences: This targeting option uses the browsing activities of your website visitors and targets users with similar interests and habits.
Retargeting: Reaches visitors who have been to your site, have shown interest, and have started the conversion process. Retargeting aims to bring those customers back with highly relevant messages that pertain to the interest they have shown while visiting the site (weddings, family travel, business, etc.)
In-Market Buyers: Reaches people whose habits suggest that they are in the final phases of the purchase conversion funnel for a product similar to yours (i.e. a hotel room in your market) and ready to make a booking.
With these options, hoteliers can target the most qualified user, allowing them to spend less and generate significantly higher returns. The possibilities for hoteliers in the display space are more exciting and accessible than ever before.
Please read "The Top Ten Questions to Ask Your Online Media Agency."
F. Recovering Abandoned Reservations
On average, only 5% of website visitors that go to a hotel website actually complete the booking.
This leaves the vast majority of website visitors unexposed to a hotel's rates and special offers. Even if a website visitor has decided to stay at the property, he or she may not feel compelled to complete the booking at that time or even via the hotel's own website.
Properties can recover abandoned reservations in multiple ways that work together:
Click here to read how an independent hotel recovered tens of thousands in abandoned bookings.
Recommended share of the budget: 5%-6%
G. Email Marketing
Living in a multi-device world means that people are connected to their email at all times. Email marketing is a low cost, effective digital marketing initiative that generates average returns of 800-1200% (HeBS Digital clients).
Being able to reach people at all times however, does come at a cost. It requires an email marketing strategy that aligns with the travel consumer who has minimal patience and a general distrust of advertising. This includes:
Recommended share of the budget: 4%-5%
H. Social Media
In the Top 10 Questions to Ask Your Online Media Agency, we discussed how social platforms such as Twitter, Facebook, and YouTube have released ad-targeting options that use the brand's own data to reach highly qualified users with relevant messages and offers.
Facebook's lookalike feature allows marketers to target people with similar characteristics as their website visitors, mobile app users, and Facebook fans. Twitter's "tailored audiences" reaches users on Twitter who have shown interest by visiting the brand's website. YouTube provides ad targeting to reach viewers based on their past interactions with the brand's videos or YouTube channel. In addition, there are travel networks available to hoteliers that retarget site visitors with ads across Facebook and Twitter, as well as mobile and the web.
A successful social media strategy also requires a strong foundation. The hotel's presence on these social media platforms should be treated as an extension of their website, and branded appropriately. This means well-designed Facebook and YouTube cover photos, Twitter profiles, Google+ cover photos, etc. Hoteliers should also invest in keeping all their social media platforms updated frequently, and to never leave a complaint unanswered.
Recommended share of the budget: 2%-4%
2. Seasonal & Business Needs
Building effective digital marketing campaigns means reaching people at various stages in their travel planning journey. Multichannel marketing campaigns are the most effective way to address concrete business needs, increase reach, and boost bookings & revenue for a need period.
This portion of the budget should incorporate your property's seasonality as well as specific business-needs (i.e. need to fill weekdays vs. weekends, occupancy needs, group cancelations, seasonal slowdowns, etc.), and also target specific high value segments. The Seasonal & Business Needs focused budget should stay flexible throughout the year. Many initiatives in the year-round budget may overlap here, however they will be organized into a multi-channel campaign that promotes one campaign theme throughout multiple channels.
To begin building a successful multi-channel plan, it's important to start by answering the 3 W's: Who, What, and When.
At HeBS Digital, we answer these questions, take the property's goals (for instance, do they need bookings over the weekend? Do they need to attract more groups?), and then brainstorm multichannel campaigns that utilize the right marketing channels effectively and, most importantly, promote one cohesive campaign message across these channels.
Reaching people at multiple touch points in this manner is a must. Google data shows that a great deal of research goes into trip planning:
It's important not to review your results of each marketing initiative in isolation of each other. You'll miss the big picture, pause campaigns that are working, and your overall revenues will greatly suffer as a whole.
Recommended share of the budget: 10%-15%
II. Digital Assets, Website Revenue Optimization Consulting, Strategy and Operations
The foundation of your digital marketing strategy, budgeting for these initiatives is crucial to the success of all of your campaigns.
1. Property Website Redesign & CMS Technology Upgrade
The difference between an ordinary hotel, resort or casino website and a great one could be measured in hundreds of thousands of dollars of missed revenue a year. Some hoteliers are mistakenly led to believe that 'going cheap' when re-designing their property's website will save money. Wrong! Not investing in the correct property website will cause you to lose money and severely damage the hotel's bottom line.
A property website must incorporate the right balance of excellent design, state-of-the-art digital technology and engaging visual and textual content, while providing an optimum user experience from top to bottom, which inevitably will boost conversions and revenues from the site.
In the multi-screen world we live in today, hoteliers must meet the needs of their guests on every device. This means investing in technology that allows for the best user experience on the three screens: desktop, mobile and tablet. This is best achieved via Adaptive Web Design aka Responsive Design on the Server Side (RESS), which allows the property website to serve the right website content in the right device category (desktop, mobile, tablet) while ensuring the maximum user experience, relevancy of information and conversions. In the following article we have identified "The Top 10 Questions Hoteliers Should Be Asking Their Website Design Vendor."
In the first half of this year, over 41% of web visitors and nearly 38% of page views were generated from non-desktop devices (mobile and tablet, HeBS Digital portfolio data). This shift should be viewed as an opportunity to increase revenue and customer engagement across all devices.
What kind of user experience should you be providing on the three screens?
Desktop users want as much information as possible. Include a minimum of 25-50 content pages per property and another 50-100 specialized marketing and landing pages featuring special packages, promotions and events. Include visual galleries with photos and videos, as well as customer reviews and other in-depth hotel and area information.
Mobile Users require short, slimmed-down content with easy access to maps and directions, real time "smart rates" and availability, a mobile booking engine and a click-to-call property reservation number.
Tablet Users are looking for deep, visually enhanced content about the property and its destination (because of those retina screens). The tablet website should also accommodate for touch-screen navigation and swiping behavior, which is how people are accustomed to navigating on a tablet. A tablet-optimized website will generate conversion rates several times higher than those of mobile devices.
The more relevant a consumer experience, the more engaged the customer is, increasing the likelihood for the conversion.
A word about the need for an upgrade to the property's Content Management System (CMS):
Today's content management system should do much more than simply allow the updating of content and photos. The ability to change your navigation, update the look of your website design with one click, publish content to social media profiles and deliver personalized dynamic content should also be a part of your CMS. Your content management system should help you maximize your presence and revenue from the three screens.
Your CMS should offer features such as:
Recommended share of the budget: 8%-10%, based on total cost amortized over 24 months.
2. Interactive Marketing Applications
Interactive marketing initiatives such as Limited Time Offers (LTOs), contests and promotions are the perfect focal point for any multichannel marketing campaign and will generate buzz and even more importantly, bookings. This type of initiative will also increase traffic to the site, encourage repeat visits, and increase time spent on the property website. Multichannel marketing campaigns that utilize Interactive Marketing Applications effectively show dramatically increased engagement and revenue. Examples include:
Recommended share of the budget: 4%-6%
3. Campaign Tracking & Website Analytics
A strong analytics tool and strategy allows for quick insights into the performance of the website and all digital marketing campaigns. The ability to receive real-time data reflecting the results of online marketing efforts translates to having access to actionable data that you can use to constantly improve website and campaign performance.
Analyzing website and digital campaign performance today should include the following two components:
1. Online reservation tracking: Use sophisticated analytics - such as Adobe Omniture SiteCatalyst - to determine contributions from and the dynamics of each of the three channels (desktop, mobile, tablet).
2. Offline reservation tracking: A recent case study by HeBS Digital and Navis demonstrated how a whopping 44% of a property's online marketing revenue was made through voice reservations, thus leading to a shift in marketing spend and increased ROIs for the client.
Recommended share of the budget: 2%-3%
4. Cloud Website Hosting and Content Delivery Network (CDN)
Search engine rankings and conversions are increasingly dependent on high download speeds. Travel consumers do not book on websites with slow download speeds. Choosing a hosting platform is about more than just keeping your website up; it has become a decision that can severely impact your revenues if not handled properly.
For example here at HeBS Digital we utilize secure, enterprise-level "Cloud" hosting with built-in redundancy and load-balancing, and CDN (Content Delivery Network) platform enabling distributed content delivery of the rich media content, both of which dramatically increase download speeds on our clients' websites, improves user experience and conversions, and improves search engine rankings that are increasingly dependent on fast download speeds.
Choose a Cloud Hosting and Content Delivery Network (CDN) platform that will allow for:
Recommended share of the budget: 2%-3%
5. Website Revenue Optimization Strategy & Consulting
A property that has a high revenue-generating website and digital marketing strategy that drives direct online bookings needs a great hotel digital marketing partner behind it. Your website revenue optimization consultant and account manager should utilize the full digital marketing toolkit: SEM, SEO, Dynamic Rate Marketing, Online Media and Retargeting, Email Marketing, Meta Search, Reservation Recovery Applications, Multi-Channel Marketing, Social Media, etc., to lead the property in achieving maximum revenue from the property website/direct online channel.
With your bottom line at stake, choose a partner that:
Any hotel that has a high revenue-generating website and a strong digital marketing strategy that drives direct online bookings needs a great hotel digital marketing partner behind it. We have identified "The Top Ten Questions to Ask Your Digital Marketing Partner."
Choose a partner that has both digital technology and digital marketing capabilities under one roof and that will help you keep up with the rapid development and marketing opportunities available in the industry today. You should not settle for anything less than the best, a partner that will lead your property in achieving maximum revenue from the property website/direct online channel.
Recommended share of the budget: 8%-10%
digital budget planning
HeBS Digital has pioneered many of the best practices in hospitality digital technology and marketing, and direct online channel best practices and strategies. The firm has won over 260 prestigious industry awards for its digital marketing and website design services, including numerous Adrian Awards, Davey Awards, W3 Awards, WebAwards, Magellan Awards, Summit International Awards, Interactive Media Awards, IAC Awards, and others.
A diverse client portfolio of hospitality clients: from restaurants to major hotel brands, luxury and boutique hotel chains, resorts and casinos, hotel management companies, franchisees and independents, and CVBs are benefiting from HeBS Digital's direct online channel strategy and digital marketing expertise. Contact HeBS Digital's consultants at (212) 752-8186 or email@example.com.
Contact: Mariana Mechoso Safer
How to Jumpstart Your Hotel's Direct Bookings through Search Engine Marketing
New LUMA Hotel Times Square Website Embodies Flair of Iconic Neighborhood
Webinar Video Available: HeBS Digital Discusses the “Key Tools to Optimizing Direct Bookings and Lowering Distributions Costs”
How to Jumpstart Your Hotel's Direct Bookings Through Multichannel Campaigns
Webinar on Key Tools to Optimizing Direct Bookings and Lowering Distribution Costs
Do You Know Where Your Hotel Website Bookers Went? Tools to Decrease Website Reservation Abandonment and Boost Direct Bookings
HeBS Digital & Google Discuss How Hoteliers Can Use Smart Data Marketing to Drive Direct Bookings and Lower Distribution Costs
How to Use Online & Voice Channel Analytics to Fully Understand True ROI from Digital Marketing
Playing Possum and Penguin: A Hotelier's Guide to Navigating Google's Recent Algorithm Updates
HeBS Digital Recognized with 8 Interactive Media Awards for Website Design & Digital Technology, Including 2 Best-in-Class Awards
Hotel Distribution Cost: The Only Cost Driver That Can Save Your Property’s Bottom Line in 2017
The Complete Guide to Choosing the Right Website CMS Technology, a New eBook Just Launched by HeBS Digital
Now Available: Q4 2016 Edition of HeBStrategy, HeBS Digital’s Hospitality Digital Technology & Marketing Strategy Whitepaper
HeBS Digital Asks Hoteliers: How Can Your Property Boost Direct Revenues 25%, Guaranteed?
HeBS Digital’s smartCMS® Website Technology Wins World Travel Award and Voted North America’s Leading Travel Merchandising Solution Provider 2016
HeBS Digital Awarded Four Travel Weekly Magellan Awards for its Best-of-Breed Design, Technology and Ability to Drive Direct Online Bookings
Automating Travel Plans: The Impact of Google’s New Travel App on Hoteliers’ Strategies
The WebAwards Recognize HeBS Digital's Industry-Leading Technology and Website Design with 7 Awards, Including Best Hotel and Lodging Website
How to Jumpstart Your Hotel's Direct Bookings Through Social Media
The Smart Hotelier’s Guide to 2017 Digital Marketing Budget Planning
Please login or register to post a comment.