August 27, 2013 - Labor and related costs have long been the single expense category in operating a hotel. In 2012, 45 percent of all dollars were spent on personnel to manage, market and, critically, deliver hospitable service to create a memorable (and hopefully positive!) guest experience. Thus, managers spend a significant portion of their time recruiting, training, and scheduling employees.

In the July 2012 issue of Lodging we noted, "As the U.S. lodging industry continues along the road to recovery and occupancy levels begin to surpass long-run average levels, hotel managers will be challenged to continue to operate on austere levels of staffing. If 2011 was any indication, it appears that operators may have already reached the point when additional employee hours are needed to provide the amenities and services typically offered when hotels are more prosperous."

Sure enough, in 2012 labor costs increased at a greater pace than did the number of occupied rooms, thus indicating a decline in productivity. To gain a better understanding of the apparent dip in payroll yield, we examined information from PKF Hospitality Research, LLC's (PKF-HR) Trends® in the Hotel Industry database.

Labor costs are a function of the hourly compensation (salaries, wages, bonuses, and benefits) paid to employees, and the number of hours they work. The hourly compensation information used in our analysis comes from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS). The change in total hours worked by employees was calculated by subtracting the change in average hourly compensation from the change in total labor costs. In 2012, total labor costs for the properties in our Trends® sample grew by 3.6 percent, while compensation grew by 1.2 percent. The result is an estimated 2.4 percent increase in the number of hours worked by employees at the average hotel in the study sample.

Compensation

The good news for hoteliers is that increases to the compensation component of labor costs continue to be suppressed. From 2002 through 2008, annual increases in hospitality compensation averaged 3.3 percent. However, since then, the average hourly amount paid to the typical hospitality employee for wages and benefits has grown by just 1.1 percent per year.

Can the low rise in hourly compensation levels be sustained? When comparing national unemployment rates to hospitality compensation, the inverse relationship between these two measures becomes evident. As the national unemployment rate surpassed 9.0 percent in 2009, annual compensation adjustments dipped below 2.0 percent. According to their April 2013 forecast, Moody's Analytics, PKF-HR's source for economic forecasts, is projecting that the national unemployment rate will remain above 6.5 percent through 2014. Therefore, it can be expected that hotel managers will not experience elevated external pressure to boost compensation.

As noted above, compensation is the product of both the salaries, wages, and bonuses (payroll) paid to employees, plus payroll taxes and employee benefits (payroll-related expenses). According to our 2013 Trends® survey, the payroll-related portion of total labor costs grew at nearly twice the pace of the payroll portion in 2012, a trend we have observed in 10 of the past 13 years. The impending mandates associated with laws surrounding universal healthcare that become effective in January 2014 portend more of the same in the years ahead.

Hours

While weakness in national employment levels will likely continue to mitigate increases in hotel labor costs, employee productivity is a concern.

In 2012, PKF-HR estimates that the total hours worked by all employees at the typical property in the Trends® sample increased by 2.4 percent. This is down from the 3.3 percent rise observed in 2011. On the surface, this appears to indicate that operators did a better job at controlling staffing during the year. However, the number of employee hours required to operate a hotel is heavily influenced by the number of rooms occupied at the property. Therefore, when comparing the 2.4 percent increase in hours to the 1.8 percent rise in occupied rooms, we see managers struggled to control the staffing required to service the increase in business volume.

Declines in productivity are something PKF-HR has observed in the past. Since 2002, the four times that the annual change in total hours worked exceeded the change in occupied rooms, the average occupancy level for the Trends® sample was greater than 69 percent. According to the March 2013 edition of PKF-HR's Hotel Horizons® forecast, national occupancy levels are forecast to increase through 2015. Therefore, it appears that U.S. hotel managers will be challenged to control staffing while facing continued increases in business volume.

A Delicate Balance

During our analysis we analyzed several factors that impact hotel labor costs. Managers have limited ability to control payroll-related expenditures (particularly those that are government mandated), and the elevated national unemployment rate (and therefore ample supply of labor) is what it is. However, operators do have the ability to schedule staff and manage productivity.

Tags: labor costs, pkf

About PKF Hospitality Research

R. Mark Woodworth is President of PKF Hospitality Research, LLC. Robert Mandelbaum is Director of Research Information Services for the firm. They are located in the firm's Atlanta office. To purchase a copy of the 2013 Trends® in the Hotel Industry report, please visit www.pkfc.com/store. This article was published in the July 2013 edition of Lodging.

Contact: Robert Mandelbaum

robert.mandelbaum@pkfc.com / 404.809.3959

Related News

U.S. Hotels in Profitable Portion of Business Cycle

PKF Hotel Investment Survey Concludes Good Times Ahead for Lodging Industry

Recovery Ends - Peak Performance to Persist - PKF Forecasts Record Performance for U.S. Hotels

Video Recap of Trends in the Hotel Industry: U.S. Hotels are in Profitability Sweet Spot says PKF

Hotel Marketing: Investing In People And Technology

U.S. Hotels In Profitability Sweet Spot: Double-Digit Gains In NOI Forecast Through 2015

Shift in Hotel Retail Impacts Revenues and Profits

U.S. Hotel Forecast: Overbuilding Is Not A Concern (Yet!)

Lodging Insights Video: PKF Shares Thoughts on Group Hotel Demand & the GDP

Accuracy Remains High for PKF's Latest Forecast Assessment of Lodging Industry

Incentive Fees On The Rise By Robert Mandelbaum and Viet Vo

PKF's Hotel Horizons® January 2014 Video Update Discussing Possible Future Supply Concerns

Lodging Insights Video Update: PKF Discusses Recent Events at Federal Reserve & Possible Impact

Hotels Pay Their Debt By Robert Mandelbaum and Viet Vo

Conference Centers: The Recovery Gathers Speed

Prosperity Equals Accuracy When it Comes to Hotel Budgets / Robert Mandelbaum & Viet Vo

Lodging Insights Video Update: PKF Discusses Current Industry Issues, Challenges and the Future

Are We There Yet? By Scott Smith MAI and Bill Morton

Should The Good News Be Even Better? PKF Provides Updated City Forecasts with a Focus on Room Rates

Lodging Insights Video Update: PKF Discusses Recent ADR Increases and What to Expect in 2014

Caribbean Hotel Market Trending Upward According to PKF Consulting USA

IACC & PKF Release "Trends® in the Conference Center Industry 2013"

Lodging Insights: PKF's Mark Woodworth Discusses Q2 2013 and What Could Derail Recovery, if Anything

Guest - Can You Spend A Dime? Hotels Struggle To Get Extra Spend In 2012 / Robert Mandelbaum

PKF Consulting

Top–Line Extends To The Bottom-Line; An Analysis of Extended Stay Hotels

PKF Survey Finds Optimism in Hotel Investments

PKF Hotel Budget Guidance for 2014: Plan for Strong Increases in Revenues and Profits

All News »

Please login or register to post a comment.