EB-5 Financing Accelerates in 2016 and Favors (1) Hotels, (2) Mixed-Use and (3) Multifamily as Top 3 Targets for EB-5 Funding
February 10, 2016 9:11am
By Jim Butler and the Global Hospitality Group®
Hotel Lawyers | Authors of www.HotelLawBlog.com
10 February 2016
Hotel Lawyer in Los Angeles at the latest EB-5 Summit
If you have been thinking about tapping into EB-5 financing for your development project, this is the time to make your decision and act quickly. If you need background on what the EB-5 program is about, how it has gone mainstream with institutional investors for several years, and is now providing a steady stream of reliable capital, please see the articles referenced at the bottom.
We think that JMBM’s Global Hospitality Group® EB-5 financing team has a pretty good perspective on the opportunity, the risks, and how to get clean execution. For the 18 months ended December 31, 2015, our team closed more than $1 billion of EB-5 financing loans, and we sourced more than $700 million of these loans for our clients.
If you have missed our reporting of key events affecting the availability of EB-5 financing here, you need to know that the EB-5 program was extended for another year through September 30, 2016 without any changes. But just as the maximum number of visas has been reached in each of the past two years, the experts expect that we will “cap out” at the maximum 10,000 visas even earlier in 2016 – possibly as early as May or June.
And the “reformers” are still out there, with proposals to revise the EB-5 program the next time it comes up for renewal. So this is a great time to move into action while EB-5 financing continues to be accessible for top developers with great projects and a strong track record.
We are confident that most people who delay will wish they had started earlier and gotten in on this great source of relatively inexpensive financing early in the game.
The NES Financial EB-5 Innovation Summit 2016 – Los Angeles, California
NES Financial is one of the top providers of administrative services for EB-5 financing. They focus on escrows and other technology-enabled services for the efficient administration of EB-5 financial transactions, 1031 exchanges and fund administration. See www.nesfinancial.com.
JMBM’s EB-5 financing team attended an NES-sponsored “Summit” in Los Angeles on February 4 at the Los Angeles City Club, and it was a great program. I particularly enjoyed the “State of the Industry” presentation by Reid Thomas, Executive Vice President of NES Financial.
Here are a few highlights and slides from Reid’s presentation, presented here with permission.
Some highlights on the state of EB-5 financings
Continued expansion of regional centers. There are now almost 800 regional centers in the United States offering to raise EB-5 capital for developers. We continue to believe that less than 10% of the regional centers have raised almost all of the EB-5 capital to date. This makes it critical that developer select the “right” regional center or the developer may spend a lot of time and money with very poor results.
Where the EB-5 projects are located. It is no surprise that most of the EB-5 activity is in California, New York, Texas and Florida. In California, Southern California dominates the picture. That said, one of our closings in December for $40 million EB-5 financing was in Nebraska. So the right developer with a great project and proper guidance can find success even outside Los Angeles or New York!
The following slide shows project activity by state in 2015.
Who is raising the capital — concentration on the most active developers. The 80-20 rule applies to EB-5 financings. 20% of the projects raise 80% of the capital and 80% of the projects raise only 20% of the capital. The 80-20 rule seems to apply to almost everything in life, and EB-5 financing is no exception.
The average EB-5 capital raise for 2015 is $50 million.
What sectors have the most EB-5 projects? (number of projects, not amount of capital)
The following slide shows the breakdown of EB-5 financing by number of projects in each industry sector. Notice that the top five sectors are:
The fastest growing segment of projects in 2015 was multifamily. Multifamily went from the number 5 referred sector in 2014 to the number 2 preferred sector in 2015, in terms of projects by industry sector.
What sectors raise the most EB-5 capital? (total dollars of capital)
In general, the amount of EB-5 capital raised roughly parallels the industry sector projects, but there are significant differences. The following slide shows the distribution of the EB-5 capital actually raised by industry sector.
Note that, in terms of capital raised, public works greatly exceeded retail/restaurant. Again, the growth in EB-5 financing for multifamily was explosive! In terms of capital raised, multifamily barely registered on the scale in 2014, but almost equaled the other top two leaders in 2015. This is an amazing growth.
What is the size of projects and the amount of EB-5 capital raised?
We specialize in assisting clients raising at least $20 million of EB-5 capital. Although there are a few exceptions, most of our sources are not very interested in raising less than that, unless it is part of a series or a template that can be repeated. Even then, the “sweet spot” that we know for EB-5 capital is substantially above $20 million.
However, it is noteworthy that NES Financial’s data shows that in 2015 almost half of the projects (by number) involved an EB-5 capital raise of less than $20 million. However, in terms of dollars raised, more than 90% involved the capital raise of $20 million or more, and more than 50% of the projects involved $100 million or more. 22% of the projects involved $500 million or more.
In historical trends, note that the target raise for EB-5 financing in 2011 was approximately $23 million. In 2014 it was more than $52 million, and in 2015 it was $47 million. This is the data that produces the average EB-5 capital raise of $50 million at the current time.
Other observations — where is/will EB-5 capital come from.
EB-5 debt continues to dominate. The sweet spot for EB-5 financing is mezzanine debt that will cost 6 or 7% per annum as an all-in cost to the developer/borrower on a 5 to 7 year term. Some experts expected that EB-5 would be used more in an equity position, but that has not developed.
China continues to be the dominant source of funds for EB-5 financings. The drop to 2nd place is so significant that it is difficult to imagine. However, Latin America is coming on as an EB-5 investment source as well as the Middle East and Gulf regions. It will be interesting to see if investors from other countries have different expectations on returns than those from the traditional Chinese investor.
However, there is a clear trend toward geographical diversification and there may be some changes. Although Columbia, Venezuela and Brazil have experienced explosions in EB-5 capital raise as high as 1400%, they still pale compared to China. However, these 3 countries have finally eclipsed Korea in terms of EB-5 capital, and Korea has historically been the number 2 source of funding for EB-5 financing.
Why you want to start raising your EB-5 capital NOW . . .
With the EB-5 program extended for another year (through September 30, 2016) without a single change in the rules, we are advising our developer clients to proceed with all due haste in pursuing their EB-5 financing. On this timing issue, our thinking is very simple:
There has been something of a hiatus or gap in EB-5 financings as developers and lenders waited to see if Congress would change the law on essential details that affect how (or even whether) a project can be structured for EB-5 — matters such as the minimum investment, how or whether one could qualify as a TEA, how the minimum new jobs requirement would be calculated, and other important business and legal details.
Now, as the program has been renewed without a single change, lenders and foreign investors are rushing to fill the pipeline again. And it is much more desirable to be at the front of the line, rather than at the back of the line.
As of December 31, 2015, JMBM’s team has closed more than $1 billion of EB-5 loans, and sourced more than $700 million of EB-5 funding for our developer clients. Please give us a call if you would like to see if we can help you.
Other articles on EB-5 Financing
To access our rich library of articles on EB-5 financing, go to www.HotelLawyer.com, scroll down the right-hand side under LEARN MORE ABOUT and click on “EB-5 Financing.” For your convenience, here are a few popular EB-5 articles that may be of interest:
EB-5 Immigrant Visa program extension signed into law — without any changes. EB-5 financing continues for new development projects.
JMBM has sourced more than $700 million of EB-5 financing for new development projects
Hotel Financing 2015: JMBM’s “preferred” EB-5 construction financing program for top developers and projects.
FAQs about EB-5 project financing for new hotel development
Hotel development & EB-5 financing: Why you don’t want to form your own regional center
Hotel development financing: How to win the race for EB-5 capital
Financing hotel development today: The 5 questions every hotel developer is asking about EB-5 financing
Hotel Lawyer to Developers: Looking for EB-5 Financing? The China “Retrogression” means you should act sooner than later!
This is Jim Butler, author of www.HotelLawBlog.com and hotel lawyer, signing off. Why don’t you give us a call (or send an email) and let us know what you working on? We would like to see if our experience might help you create value or avoid unnecessary pitfalls. Who’s your hotel lawyer?
Tags: jim butler,
global hospitality group,
hotel law blog
Jim Butler is a founding partner of JMBM, and the founder and chairman of JMBM’s Global Hospitality Group® and Chinese Investment Group™. He is recognized as one of the top hotel lawyers in the world and has authored or co-authored The HMA & Franchise Agreement Handbook, How to Buy a Hotel Handbook, and The Lenders Handbook. Jim has led the Global Hospitality Group® in more than $71 billion of hotel transactional experience, involving more than 3,800 hotel properties located around the globe.
Contact: Jim Butler
Our Perspective. We represent hotel owners, developers and investors. We have helped our clients find business and legal solutions for more than $71 billion of hotel transactions, involving more than 3,800 properties all over the world. We bring this experience to any hotel project — big or small. Let’s explore how it might work for you.
For more information, please contact Jim Butler at email@example.com or +1 (310) 201-3526.
California Labor & Employment Law Update: Key Changes in 2017 and What’s Slated for 2018
ADA Compliance & Defense Lawyer Update: 99 ADA Lawsuits Dismissed as Fraudulent and Malicious
Homeland Security Warns Against Threats to US Infrastructure
Resort Fee Litigation Advisory Group: How to Avoid Litigation on Resort Fees and Other Mandatory Hotel Charges
Hotel Lawyer: Tips on Negotiating Your Annual Hotel Budget
Resort Fee Litigation Advisory Group: How Resort Fees Became an Explosive $2.7 Billion Issue
Resort Fee Litigation Advisory Group: National Task Force of 47 Attorneys General Goes After Resort Fees
Resort Fee Litigation Advisory Group: The FTC Takes Aim at Hotel Resort Fees (Again) - The FTC 2017 Report
Resort Fee Litigation Advisory Group: Impending Eruption of Litigation over Resort Fees?
Hotel Lawyer: Tax Alert for Partnerships and LLCs
EB-5 Finance Lawyer: President Trump's Budget Deal Includes Extension of EB-5 Through 12-8-17
EB-5 Financing Lawyer: What JMBM Does to Help Developers With EB-5 Construction Financing
EB-5 Financing Lawyer: Why You Do NOT Want to Form Your Own Regional Center
EB-5 Financing Lawyer: The 5 Questions Every Developer is Asking About EB-5 Financing
JMBM's Global Hospitality Group Announces the Publication of an EB-5 Handbook for Developers
EB-5 Financing Lawyer: EB-5 Construction Financing Term Sheet for Top Developers
EB-5 Financing Lawyer: FAQs: Essentials of EB-5 Construction Financing for Developers
EB-5 Financing Lawyer: More than $1.5 Billion of EB-5 Construction Financing Closed for JMBM Clients
EB-5 Finance Lawyer: Are Hotels Still the Darling of EB-5 Financing?
EB-5 Finance Lawyer: Tips to Avoid the 6 Most Common Mistakes Developers Make With EB-5
Please login or register to post a comment.