News for the Hospitality Executive
Beyond Vanity Metrics: Measuring ROI in Social Media
by Daniel Edward Craig
September 18, 2012
It’s that time of year again when hotel marketers are in the hot seat, trying to justify the money they’ve requested in next year’s budget. And no line item is more contentious than social media.
“You want how much?” barks the general manager. “Where’s the ROI?”
“Uh … well, we plan to increase our Facebook likes by 30% … and double our Twitter following … and, um … increase engagement.”
“Engagement? Engagement doesn’t fill rooms!”
The reality is, if you try to draw a direct line between social media and revenue you’re likely to come up short. This isn’t to say there aren’t significant revenue benefits to social media; they’re just hard to trace. A recent eConsultancy/Adobe survey of over 650 marketers worldwide found that only 12% are able to track the effects of social media activity on revenue.
And yet without hard metrics we have no accountability, no understanding of how social impacts business, and little idea of the strategies to pursue and the resources to dedicate. So we need to sort through the multitudes of available data to find meaningful insight and measurable results. Fortunately, there are tools to help.
But first, what are you measuring?
Without objectives, there’s nothing to measure. Above all, driving revenue must be behind everything we do—otherwise, why bother? A key metric here is attribution: assigning credit to the sources that lead to bookings.
Asking guests and clients how they heard about your hotel and why they booked will help, but it only tells part of the story. Travel planning is not a linear process. It can involve a multitude of sources, and like in hockey, the assist is as important as the goal.
Driving revenue is one of several objectives, all of which can contribute to the bottom line. According to Nielsen’s latest Trust in Advertising survey, consumers trust the opinions of other consumers more than any other advertising source. A primary objective of social media then must be to harness its powerful sharing tools to get people talking about and recommending your brand—to get them selling for you.
Other core objectives include building awareness, increasing guest satisfaction and managing reputation. Measuring ROI on these objectives isn’t that straight forward, either. But there are metrics that indicate our success, and they can be divided into Social, Review and Website Analytics. Track these metrics on a weekly basis and compile them into a report to present at monthly reviews and in the annual budget meeting.
1. Social Analytics
Adding a booking widget to your Facebook page is the most obvious way to monetize social media, but you’re not likely to see more than a trickle of rooms. People go to Facebook to socialize, not to shop.
So we rely on so-called “vanity metrics” like the number of followers on Facebook, Twitter, Google+, Pinterest and other networks. But they provide only a partial and sometimes distorted view. Your goal is to build a community of people with a shared affinity for your brand, not of people who liked your page to win a contest and will never pay for a room. Quality is more important than quantity.
For more meaningful insight we look at engagement. Facebook disclosed this year that the average post from a brand page is seen by only 16% of its fans. The EdgeRank algorithm determines who sees posts based on affinity, weight and recency. The more followers interact with your content, the more they and their friends will see.
So key metrics include Reach, Engaged Users, Talking About, Virality and Were Here, all accessible through Facebook Insights. We also need to know how we reach people, whether through Organic, Paid or Viral channels.
Similar analytics are provided by YouTube and Foursquare; for Twitter you can use a free tool like HootSuite. A paid integrated analytics tool will help you track activity on all major social networks.
2. Review Analytics
Guest reviews and ratings represent your most important metrics because they reflect guest satisfaction and are directly correlated with demand, conversions and the rates you can charge.
Aside from ratings and rankings on individual review sites and OTAs, key review metrics include aggregate scores across sites, review volume and sentiment, and comparisons to hotels in your comp set, region and group. You need to look at both big-picture and granular data here. Break metrics down by department and by attributes like service and cleanliness to identify areas of strength and weakness.
Much like commentary on social networks, review commentary is difficult to measure because it’s unstructured content and often contains mixed feedback. For meaningful insight, comments must be qualified as positive, negative or neutral and tracked over time to identify patterns. A reputation management tool like ReviewPro will aggregate, organize and score your reviews from across the Web and will analyze sentiment for actionable insight.
By digging deep into review analytics, you can analyze the impact of reviews on demand and rates on various channels—and vice versa—and use the data to optimize rates and distribution, all of which will lead directly to the bottom line.
3. Website Analytics
Your website remains your primary means of promoting your hotel online, and social media plays an increasingly important role. New features on Google Analytics help you determine which social networks drive visitors to your site, what visitors do on your site, and which pages are shared on social networks.
Further, Google provides attribution data like Last Interaction and Assisted Conversions as well as conversion paths to help you determine social media’s part in driving direct bookings at each online stage of the decision journey.
Again, be sure to assign booking and tracking codes to measure the results of specific campaigns and content as well as overall performance.
Other things to consider when assessing ROI include the influence of social activity and content on search engine visibility and rankings, the ability to execute highly targeted campaigns using social psychographics, and increases in direct bookings and loyalty generated by social connections. Moreover, there is great value in real-time feedback and significant cost savings compared to paid media and print collateral.
But be careful not to exaggerate the role of social media. Email blasts, OTAs and cost-per-click are more efficient means of driving direct revenue, and most travelers still book via traditional channels like Web, phone and GDS. Social media supports these activities by amplifying paid media and driving traffic to these channels.
Measuring social media ROI can be complex and imprecise, but it will get easier as social analytics become more integrated with CRM and revenue data. Make it a priority. It will help you get approval for the budget you need to do social effectively—making that hot seat just a little cooler.
Want to learn more? Join Josiah Mackenzie, experts from the hotel industry and me for our next ReviewPro webinar: In the Hot Seat: How to Measure ROI in Social Media
About the Author
Daniel Edward Craig is a former hotel general manager turned consultant specializing in social media strategy and online reputation management. He collaborates with ReviewPro as Client Engagement Advisor.
For more info visit www.DanielEdwardCraig.com.
Copyright © 2012 Daniel Edward Craig. All rights reserved.
Daniel Edward Craig
Pricing Complaints to Personal Attacks: How to Respond to Challenging
Guest Reviews / Daniel Edward Craig / August 2012
Never Sleeps: How to Use Social Networks to Drive Higher Guest
Satisfaction / Daniel Edward Craig / July 2012
Hotels, Winning at the Reputation Management Game Means Taking a Team
Approach / Daniel Edward Craig / June 2012
Social Media Savvy is Your Hotel's General Manager? / Daniel Edward
Craig / March 2012
to Social Media, Part II: InterContinental Hotels Group / Daniel
Edward Craig / February 2012
to Social Media, Part I: citizenM Hotels / Daniel Edward Craig /
for Destination Marketing Organizations / Daniel Edward Craig /
Do Travelers Want? Setting Hotel and Travel Marketing Priorities in 2012
/ Daniel Edward Craig / January 2012
Hotel Groups Ready for Total Transparency in Traveler Reviews? /
Daniel Edward Craig / January 2012
Exploring: Social Media and Reputation Management in Canada’s Tourism
Strategy; An interview with Greg Klassen, Senior Vice President of
Marketing Strategy and Communications, Canadian Tourism Commission
/ Daniel Edward Craig / October 2011
Media Coercion: How far should hotels go to please and appease guests?
/ Daniel Edward Craig / September 2011
Media Ambush: When Hotel Guests Go on the Attack / Daniel Edward
Craig / September 2011
a Virtuous Cycle: Integrating Online Reputation Management into
Operations and Culture / Daniel Edward Craig / September 2011
is going Places - is your business ready for the ride? / Daniel
Edward Craig / August 2011
to Make Compelling Video Content for Hotels / Daniel Edward Craig /
to Use Social Media to Tap Into the Burgeoning Market of Chinese
Travelers; An interview with Jens Thraenhart of Dragon Trail /
Daniel Edward Craig / July 2011
Sample Social Media Policy for Hotels / Daniel Edward Craig / June
Stanley Cup Riots in Vancouver: a Case Study in Online Reputation
Crisis Management / Daniel Edward Craig / June 2011
Review Clinic is Open / Daniel Edward Craig / June 2011
with Yelp for Hotels / Daniel Edward Craig / June 2011
to Optimize Your TripAdvisor Listing / Daniel Edward Craig / May
Reputation Manager: the Newest Position in Hotels? / Daniel Edward
Craig / April 2011
Satisfaction Index: the Next Big Measure of Hotel Performance? /
Daniel Edward Craig / April 2011
Networking or Social Notworking? Social Media as a Sales Tool for Hotels
/ Daniel Edward Craig / March 2011
Search, Video, and Nimble Marketing: Tips for Hotels from Google’s UK
Travel Industry Manager / Daniel Edward Craig / March 2011
or Big-Box? Social Media Stirs the Sleeping Micro-Giant of the Lodging
Industry / Daniel Edward Craig / February 2011
Media and Storytelling for Hotels / Daniel Edward Craig / February
Round-up of Social Media and Reputation Monitoring Tools for Hotels
/ Daniel Edward Craig / February 2011
Confidence to be Transparent: Why Accor Hotel Group Posts TripAdvisor
Reviews Directly to its Website; An interview with Jean-Luc
Chrétien, Executive VP Marketing & Distribution, Accor /
Daniel Edward Craig / December 2010
Positive Spin on Negative Reviews / Daniel Edward Craig / November
After Midnight: How to Avoid Being Bumped from Your Hotel / Daniel
Edward Craig / October 2010
|Why Everyone Gets a Hotel Room Upgrade... But You / Daniel Edward Craig / April 2008|