|By Julie Wernau, Chicago
TribuneMcClatchy-Tribune Regional News
October 26, 2009 - --The union representing 6,000 hotel workers in downtown Chicago and 15,000 hospitality workers in the Chicago area said Friday that contract negotiations are "very, very far from settlement."
The contracts for the 31 hotels expired Aug. 31, the first time in a decade the hotels and union have failed to reach an agreement near the settlement deadline, a spokeswoman for Unite Here said. The news comes after 3,000 union members voted overwhelmingly Thursday to authorize a strike in San Francisco. "Things have gotten really bad," said Annemarie Strassel, spokeswoman for Unite Here Local 1. "I think that employers see the bad economy as an opportunity to ram through proposals."
Unite Here has focused in on Chicago-based Hyatt after the chain fired 98 non-union Boston hotel workers in September and outsourced the work to lower-paid employees at a Georgia company. The same month, nearly 195 Unite Here workers and community supporters were arrested for protesting hotel cutbacks at the Park Hyatt Chicago near Michigan Avenue.
This year, as with the last contract negotiations in 2006, the union is negotiating with the large hotel chains separately rather than as a group through the Hotel Employers Labor Relations Association. John Schafer, vice president and managing director for Hyatt Regency Chicago, said Hyatt has been diligent in meeting with the union but that negotiations were taking longer because of the arrangement.
Arnie Karr, chief operating officer at the labor relations association, who has been sitting in on union negotiations with the Hilton, Hyatt and Starwood chains, said a group of smaller hotels is waiting to see how the talks pan out and likely would adopt similar agreements. The main sticking point, he said, is health insurance.
Contracts proposed by the Starwood and Hyatt chains, Strassel said, would render up to 50 percent of workers ineligible for health insurance. Costs for coverage for the remaining group would increase significantly. "Our folks are housekeepers and dishwashers."
Schafer said union employees -- with salaries starting at $30,000 for a housekeeper -- have never had to "pay a penny" for health insurance. "We want our people to have health insurance, we want it to be affordable. With the huge increases in costs over the last 10 years, we're just saying it's time to look at the things a bit differently," he said.
The union also is concerned about overtime. Hyatt laid off about 19 percent of its staff at the Hyatt Regency between November 2008 and March. Between December 2008 and April, the same hotel scheduled 46 percent of its staff for overtime, the union said. Schafer said overtime is no higher than last year.
"The company has made record profits over the last decade," Strassel said of Hyatt. "Now that they're going public they're going to be flooded with cash and they're telling workers at the table it's a bad economy."
The Pritzker family -- which owns 85 percent of the Hyatt hotel chain -- stands to gain $900 million from a proposed initial public offering of 38 million shares. The chain itself won't receive proceeds from the proposed stock sale, according to the latest prospectus filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission. The company's profits are down materially from last year, but the chain holds very little debt, SEC filings show.
"If there's work to be done, why aren't we bringing people back to work?" Strassel said. "Of course, it's because the company wants to avoid paying health care benefits."
A vote to strike at Chicago's Starwood hotels is on the table for Monday night and demonstrations are planned. A Starwood spokeswoman did not return a call for comment Friday. A Hilton spokesman was not available to comment on the Chicago negotiations, but a statement from Hilton said the chain has a long history of constructive, cooperative relationships with unions.
Strassel did not know if the union would strike at Hyatt hotels. "At this point, anything is a possibility. We're very, very far from settlement," she said.
To see more of the Chicago Tribune, or to subscribe to the newspaper, go to http://www.chicagotribune.com.
Copyright (c) 2009, Chicago Tribune
Distributed by McClatchy-Tribune Information Services. For reprints, email firstname.lastname@example.org, call 800-374-7985 or 847-635-6550, send a fax to 847-635-6968, or write to The Permissions Group Inc., 1247 Milwaukee Ave., Suite 303, Glenview, IL 60025, USA.