News for the Hospitality Executive
What Does the Current Financial Crisis Mean
to Us in the Hospitality Industry?
|By Jim Butler, Hotel Lawyer | Author of www.HotelLawBlog.com
- October 6 2008 -
The Panic of 2008 is creating investment opportunities and hazards that haven't been seen for decades. Whether or not the $700 billion bailout bill passes, many will go bankrupt. Many will get rich. But many hundreds of billions of dollars of assets will change hands in the coming months. Cash will be king. Due diligence will matter, and you will find out who your friends really are.
Hetty Green, one of the world's most successful investors who lived in the 19th century said, "Next to my children I love a good panic more than anything else."
In this article, I want to give you one hotel lawyer's collection of "idea nuggets" gathered at the recent Phoenix Lodging Conference, some data presented there by the experts, and tell you why the deleveraging of the economy -- and the hospitality industry -- will create opportunities and problems of the greatest magnitude in recent memory.
Just as Hetty Green loved her children, I love a vibrant, healthy economy and a prospering lodging industry. But I don't have any silver bullets when the spirits of panic and financial crisis present themselves. So like Hetty Green, next to a vibrant economy, I can find much to love about a good panic. The opportunities are incredible, and they are finally upon us.
The Panic of 2008 -- "Idea Nuggets"
Some of the "idea nuggets" I gleaned at the recent Phoenix Lodging Conference will set the stage for what is about to happen. Here are a few sound bites I picked up at meetings with industry leaders. I know the authors of all of them, but many are too "shy" or would find it politically unattractive to have their candid views aired in public. All of them are colored by the lenses and beliefs I hold. So brilliance belongs to the speakers, but I take all blame for my perceptions if wrong.
• Jan Freitag, Smith Travel: "Hold the rate in 08 and maybe we will be fine in 09"What does Financial Crisis mean to us in the hospitality industry?
Here it is in straight street English:
• The Liquidity Crisis or Panic of 2008 will be a scary driver in hotel values. First, all the "smart money" will leave hotel financing and hotel purchases for the more lucrative purchase of discounted notes. Why finance or buy properties at "yesterdays prices" when the lenders, driven by capital emergencies imposed by regulators and accounting rules, are forced to sell their portfolios and notes at deep discounts to get cash. The bailout legislation will not necessarily solve this problem -- it depends on the price at which they buy.
• For more than a year, the "smart money" and vultures have been waiting on the sidelines for deep discounts in note values, figuring the lenders would be forced to discount deeply when they could no longer afford to hold. Property owners with well-performing properties would not be first. It has taken a long time, but now the major mortgage bankers are seeing hotel debt regularly being sold at 30% or more discounts. Where possible, companies are buying their own debt because they feel that they are the best bargains in the market. In urgent situations, some debt is now being transacted at $.11 on the dollar even though virtually all of this debt is fully performing (ESA's mezzanine debt).
• Most hotels continue to perform well, at least in the major markets. According to Jan Freitag of STR, occupancy year to date through August 2008 is still around 70% for luxury, upper upscale and upscale hotels. But if they are starved for capital, because it is all going to deeply discounted notes, sooner or later the value of viable, performing hotels will be driven into the ground. Lower values are created by higher cap rates, falling revenues, fire-sale prices from liquidation of assets of insolvent lenders, and an absence of lenders and buyers in the marketplace.
• Ultimately, the hotel industry is driven by the growth or decrease in the US GDP, the availability of airline seats to take people to destinations, the cost of oil, the increase in hotel rooms supply, and the demand for hotel rooms. The US economy has remained remarkably resilient until now, but is staggering in the Panic of 2008 and the indecisive government position. According the PKF, Airline capacity is being cut and will be cut further before November 1, 2008. The decline in airline seat capacity alone will cause a 1 to 1.5% decline in hotel room demand. Although the cost of oil fluctuates, the generally higher price levels discourage travel for both business and leisure travelers. Hotel rooms supply is increasing at more than 2.5% a year -- well above 20 year averages -- is overwhelming canal flat to declining occupancy growth. We say "hold the rate" but the will or capacity to resist rate cuts may fall off a cliff.
Benefits and detriments of leverage, and the vicissitudes of changing cap rates and LTVs
We have talked about cap rates and their critical importance on hotel values. They go hand in hand with leverage -- debt coverage ratios (DCRs) and loan to value ratios (LTVs).
To emphasize this point made earlier about cap rates, if a hotel produces $1 million in NOI, at a 5% cap rate, it is worth $20, million, at a 7% cap rate, it is worth $14 million, and at a 10% cap rate, it is only worth $10 million.
The chart below shows the value implied at three different cap rates -- 5%, 7%, and 10% for NOI at $1 million, $700,000, and $500,000. I selected these cap rates because many hotels have been valued in the 5%-6% cap rate range in the past couple years, and many experts at the Lodging Conference seem to think we are headed back to 10% cap rates or more.
Of course it is worth remembering that many are now anticipating BOTH an increase in cap rates AND a decrease in NOI. Therefore, it is entirely possible that a hotel valued only a year or two ago at $20 million (with $1 million of NOI at a 5% cap rate) could be worth only $5 million to $7 million at a 10% cap rate with a 50% or 30% reduction in NOI. -- down from the original $10 - 20 million based on 2007 NOI.
And in a deleveraging economy, if LTVs (loan to value ratios) drop to 50%-60% from their former 70%-80%, the financeability of a property valued in 2006 or 2007 at $20 million could go from $16 million (80% of $20 million) to $2.5 million (50% of the $5 million valuation resulting from a 10% cap rate on $500,000 in NOI). Numbers will vary, but you see the mind boggling difference between a property that can justify a loan of $16 million (when valued at a 5% cap rate and 80% LTV) to $2.5 million (when valued at a 10% cap rate and 50% LTV). There is a financing "gap" of $13.5 million, when the effects of the hypothetical changes in cap rate, NOI and LTV all collide.
Opportunity or Crisis?
It all depends on where you stand. If you have cash and liquidity, you will be KING (or QUEEN). Otherwise, these times may be more than merely interesting, and you may want to consult your hotel bankruptcy lawyer. In fact, even as a King or Queen (with cash), these are likely to be times when your hotel bankruptcy lawyer will be your best friend to navigate these perilous waters. Relationships and access to the "right people" will also be critical.
P.S. In case you want to know a little more about Hetty Green ("Next to my children I love a good panic more than anything else."). According to American Heritage Magazine, in inflation-adusted dollars, Hetty Green is the richest American woman in history. When she died at age 81 in 1916, her estate was valued at more than $100 million, which would be the equivalent of $17 billion today. In her own day, Hetty was more famous for her eccentricities and her parsimony than for her wealth.
About the Author:
Jim Butler is one of the top hotel lawyers in the world. GOOGLE “hotel lawyer” or “hotel mixed-use” or “condo hotel lawyer” and you will see why. He devotes 100% of his practice to hospitality, representing hotel owners, developers and lenders. Jim leads JMBM’s Global Hospitality Group®—a team of 50 seasoned professionals with more than $40 billion of hotel transactional experience, involving more than 1,000 properties located around the globe. In the last 5 years alone, they have brought their practical advice to more than 80 “hotel-enhanced mixed-use” projects, a term Jim coined to fill a void in industry lexicon. This term describes one of the hottest developments in real estate-where hotels work together with shopping center, residential, office, retail, spa and sports facility components to mutually enhance the entire project’s excitement and success. Jim and his team are more than “just” great hotel lawyers. They are also hospitality consultants and business advisors. They are deal makers. They can help find the right operator or capital provider. They know who to call and how to reach them. They are a major gateway of hotel finance, facilitating the flow of capital with their legal skill, hospitality industry knowledge and ability to find the right “fit” for all parts of the capital stack. Because they are part of the very fabric of the hotel industry, they are able to help clients identify key business goals, assemble the right team, strategize the approach to optimize value and then get the deal done. Jim is the author of the Hotel Law Blog, www.HotelLawBlog.com. He can be reached at +1 310.201.3526 or email@example.com.
|Also See:||Tough Sledding Ahead for Hotel Industry / Karen Johnson / September 2008|
|Agreement on Bailout Bill? The ''Emergency Economic Stabilization Act of 2008" / Jim Butler / September 2008|