|By Kyle Teal, Florida Keys Keynoter,
MarathonMcClatchy-Tribune Regional News
May 9, 2007 - --The state Legislature adjourned Friday with a
bill heading to Gov. Charlie Crist's desk that would require
installation of carbon monoxide detectors in hotel rooms across Florida
by July 1, 2008. But the first of 27 lawsuits against the DoubleTree
Grand Key Resort is likely to see its first appearance in court a few
The legislative initiative was a result of lobbying on behalf
of Richard Lueders, father of Thomas Lueders, an aspiring writer who
died of carbon monoxide poisoning while vacationing at the Key West
resort in December. If signed as expected by Crist, the mandate would
require detectors in all public lodgings as well as be installed no
more than 10 feet away from bedrooms in homes or apartments built after
July 1, 2008, with adjoining garages, gas heaters, fireplaces or other
The bill, sponsored by Rep. Eduardo Gonzalez, R-Hialeah, is an
effort to prevent deaths such as Lueders'. Some 500 Americans die each
year from the poisonous gas, according to the U.S. Centers for Disease
Control. Its study also indicates that 15,000 Americans are poisoned
from unintentional, non-fire-related carbon monoxide.
The symptoms of carbon monoxide poisoning include nausea and
dizziness, and according to the center's Web site, can be prevented
with simple measures including:
-- Having oil, gas or coal-burning appliances annually checked
by a technician.
Gonzalez sponsored the bill in honor of the late Janelle
Bertot and Anthony Perez of Miami-Dade, who died from carbon monoxide
poisoning in their car in Weston in 2004.
Richard and Susan Lueders are now involved in a civil suit set
for April 2008 against the DoubleTree, where a lethal mistake in the
fourth-floor boiler room caused the colorless, odorless gas to leak
into Thomas and Richard Lueders' room next door. Besides the Lueders
suit, there are 26 others against the DoubleTree, says attorney Ira
Leesfield, who represents all 26, including the Smith family of Iowa,
who stayed in the same Room 416 Thomas and Richard Lueders did.
"These people had a defective hotel," Leesfield said. The
Lueders are represented by West Palm Beach attorney Gregory Barnhart of
Searcy, Denney, Scarola and Shipley. "I think this is an excellent
case," Barnhart said. "They [the resort] had notice and they ignored
Barnhart added that the hotel's actions cross the boundaries
of "negligence" and could easily constitute "recklessness." According
to Barnhart, Richard and Thomas Lueders experienced a hypoxic injury,
one that binds red carbon monoxide to blood cells, depriving them of
necessary oxygen. Thomas Lueders was treated for his illness.
The DoubleTree's shoddy repairs and adjustments made to a boiler room next to Room 416 led to the death of 26-year-old Richard, according to investigations completed by the state Fire Marshal's Office and the Key West Police Department. After the Monroe County State Attorney's Office reviewed those reports and conducted an investigation of its own, the office said it could not prove anything criminal occurred.
Copyright (c) 2007, Florida Keys Keynoter, Marathon
Distributed by McClatchy-Tribune Information Services. For reprints, email email@example.com, call 800-374-7985 or 847-635-6550, send a fax to 847-635-6968, or write to The Permissions Group Inc., 1247 Milwaukee Ave., Suite 303, Glenview, IL 60025, USA.